
Many of us, myself included, come from a dysfunctional family which adds a lot of weight to the challenges of caregiving. I have read stores on various threads on other topics and decided it would be good to have a thread just for this topic for people to share, vent and discuss.
The idea for this thread originated on the thread named "The Caregiver....How are YOU doing today?"
I just read your post, and I want to congratulate you!
Yes, many times to the detriment of many caregivers health....and all too often, ridden with guilt to do anything on their own behalf. This kind of a scenario really gets to me also, when one hears that an in-law as yourself is caring for other's mom, meanwhile they have other children who do nothing.
You have done an amazing thing for yourself, and great that your husband is on your side. It takes a lot of courage, and sticking to one's guns to accomplish this.
Hopefully a post such as yours will encourage some others here, to do the same.
Much Love & Light! Margeaux
The next workday, I went down to DMV and signed over my car legally to my father. Learned how important it is to sign over the car so that I will no longer be legally responsible for it and the one driving it. So, when my 2nd car became age 12, I was spending more money on repairs than I would of a new car's monthly payments. Bro Assumed that I was going to give him this car. Nope. I gave it to sis, legally signed it over to her (yep, learned my lesson well).
Austin, I have learned since then that when bro is nice to me - to watch out. He's after something. When father dies, he is the executor.
I, have sisters that are not physically abusive, but emotionally. This past Thanksgiving all were invited here, one sister and her family came, the other declined which I was happy about. The sister that came had already started this battle that continues to this day about who is to care for my mom. She wrote a 5-page letter two weeks before Thanksgiving, sent to my mom's CPA, and I suspect two attorneys that have worked with my mom, and who know who else packed with absolute lies about how I had spent mom's money, of course all of which can be documented and disclosing things I had told her about my life that were in confidence, and some things were 35 years ago. Would I have ever thought she would try to use these against me and enhance her story by false accusations? NEVER IN A MILLION YEARS!
Christmas came and I was relieved that I did not receive an invitation to their homes. I was not going to enter someone else's territory with everything that was going on. It meant I spent Christmas alone, but I would rather be alone than spend time with two faced, narcissistic, lying siblings.
And the holidays are upon us when we all start making plans. I plan to spend Christmas alone again, and may have an open house type thing for Thanksgiving, not a big sit down dinner. You do not need to subject yourself to holidays with your brother.
A unique caregiver training program
At Dementia Dynamics our mission is to improve the
lives of those with dementia and their caregivers
About Us
What makes us unique?
Our Book
A Pocket Guide for the Alzheimer's Caregiver
Curriculum
Our unique training program
Resources
Resources for reference
Blog
Advice for caregivers
Contact
Get in touch or schedule a speaker
When Nothing Stops the Violence
February 3, 2011
My father-in-law was an upstanding citizen in his small town — chairman of the Administrative Board at the Methodist church, city councilman, Scout troop leader, etc. He led the kind of life we would all hope any son of ours would lead. He was a wonderful husband, great dad and a loving grandfather. He NEVER abused anyone — wife, child, employee, ANYONE. That is, until he got Alzheimer’s disease.
I have touched on the subject of violence before, but it bears revisiting. My father-in-law had an interesting variation of the Alzheimer’s disease theme, which closely resembled “fronto-temporal dementia.” This form of dementia causes incredible behavioral problems in the patient, because the frontal lobe of the brain (located behind the forehead) is the center of judgment and self-control, among other things. It also seems to progress more rapidly than regular Alzheimer’s, so behavioral problems often arise very rapidly.
With clarity of hindsight, we can see subtle personality changes and uncharacteristic behavior before his diagnosis. The main occurrence that comes to mind was when he grew very angry with the church trustees when they ordered a diseased tree in the church yard to be cut down. He visited the trustees in their homes one Sunday afternoon and told them very emphatically what he thought about their tree-cutting — completely uncharacteristic behavior for my father-in-law.
As his disease progressed, this gentle man grew physically violent, pushing down my mother-in-law on his way to the bathroom. He was very strong and physically, very healthy. As he lost his language function (another characteristic of when the frontal lobe of the brain is affected), he could only say a few phrases over and over. He loved to remind us, “I can put 200 pounds over my head!” And he really could. When that strength turned against a loved one or a caregiver, injury sometimes resulted.
I addressed how to deal with physically violent dementia patients in an earlier blog, so I will attempt not to be repetitive. Suffice it to say that sometimes he was impossible to deal with. Whatever the cause, he had agitation, obsessive / compulsive tendencies, and anger management issues. Yes, most of the time, if you approached him correctly, he would not become violent. However, he had multiple caregivers in the 7 facilities he went through in 2 years. There is no way perfect behavior on their part and his could be assured.
First of all, doctors tried medications. The difficulty is that all medications, no matter how seemingly benign, have side effects. The choice before the physicians and family is, are the benefits worth the side effects? The answer is, sometime yes and sometimes no. In cases my father-in-law’s case, I can tell you that medications were essential to controlling his behavior, even with their myriad negative side effects.
As the disease progressed, he was increasingly difficult to deal with, even with multiple medications. Unlike many patients, his physical condition did not deteriorate like his mental condition. The crisis came in the spring of 2006, when he was sending nursing home workers to the emergency room with regularity and we lived in real fear that he would seriously harm or kill someone.
At that point, we knew he required more serious psychiatric care than he could get in any outpatient setting. He needed to be admitted to the geriatric dementia psychiatry facility in the state mental hospital, but the only way this could happen was to have him committed through the probate court system.
Every state is different, but in Alabama, the probate judge appoints an attorney to represent the patient and the family hires its own attorney. Two healthcare professionals (doctors and / or nurse practitioners) are required to testify to the patient’s condition. A family member also testifies. Prior to the hearing, the attorney for the patient investigates the situation and then, makes her recommendations under oath to the court at the hearing. In our case, my father-in-law, who would have been unable to answer questions for himself, was not required to be present. After the hearing my father-in-law was transferred to the Mary Stark Harper Center at Bryce Hospital. This place was an incredible blessing to my father-in-law and our family. At this in-patient facility, he was placed on a cocktail of medications which calmed his violent tendencies and for the 16 remaining months of his life, he was peaceful.
One of the hardest things my husband has ever done was to testify that his father was a danger to himself and others. However, he knew if his father had 5 minutes of sanity, he would choose to be committed a million times rather than harm anyone once. If you are in this situation, you can console yourself with that
Shoes down the stairs brings back memories. I was 13 or 14 and at the dinner table my mom got into a heated discussion about school integration. I was dismissed from the dinner table and went to go downstairs to my room. I was followed by a phone book that also hit me in the head. My mom never could tolerate disagreements of any sort. And being the oldest, I broke her in for the other two self-centered, narcissistic sisters.
What on earth!!!!! This admitted behavior by you about your brother, should in no way, shape or form be tolerated. You can read and listen to all the advice you want about setting boundaries. But if you don't put things in order in your own way of thinking, then it's only theories.
I had someone in my life until just a few years ago, who behaved like this, which was mom's narcissistic sister. She bullied my sister and me very much because we are the women in the family. My two brothers, not so much.
Although, she didn't quite agress upon us as much as you've indicated your brother has, still she managed to do it one tooooo many times, IMO. Here too,
because mother had this sick co-dependent relationship w/her, our aunt was allowed full reign.
About 12 yrs. ago when my dad was in the peak of his cancer, I was living at my parents. So was she, because truth be told.....they always somehow allowed her to cross boundaries and live there at the family home, for a variety of reasons.
One day on my way to work about 8:00 a.m., I got to the bottom of the stairs.
She literally threw a pair of shoes, one hitting my head as I was on my way out the door. Shortly after this, she unfortunately enticed me into a physical encounter with her. Mind you, she was an elder of about 81 yrs., of age. Do you think that either of my parents put a stop to it? As demonstrated by comments to me made by both dad and mom,, it was abundantly obvious they'd taken her side. I hate to have to put it this way, but I think my two parents were two weenies, when it came to how they viewed her, they let her get away with murder. The final blow for me came out of this fight.....which basically I was fending her off, because she made the first move on me. Later, mom asked me,
why I would do something like this, also, that her sister was planning to report me. Well, this is ALL, I had to hear, wasn't like the physical fight was bad enough. This has a lot to do with, why later after dad passed, I was very up front w/mother telling her, I could no longer live in that household, given her sister was there. I was done! I'm sure part of the reason, that I'm not the main caregiver, now for mother. You see, we inherited the care of that battle ax, (our aunt) because she had no children.
Really, the only way to put a boundary between you and this kind of abuse, is to stop physically going there, as in visiting. Sometimes, unfortunately we really have to take these kinds of steps. Don't forget.....you place yourself in danger, if he's barricading and making these kinds of threats towards you.
Be strong, be careful,
Much Love & Light! Margeaux
wanted to address others and I will after I have had a nap
All I want to do this weekend is sleep and eat chocolate! I think I am recovering from something more than the head bang. My sinuses have been quite sore but getting better. Sleep is a good thing. We are on severe thunderstorm watch, and the weather is cool and muggy - good for napping.
More later
He instead criticizes everything else about me and seems to view me in this extremely negative light, that really and truly is so uncalled for given my history... Example: for the past 15 years that I've lived out of the area, I never missed a single holiday season in Indianapolis, where my brother and other family live, and I always brought presents for his children, and for him and his wife, I've participated and helped out with the variety of holidays they host at their house... I've been a good sister to him, I really have. He typically greets me when I arrive "home for the holidays" with a sneer, a derogatory joke, or just ignores me... literally. I've always thought that behavior of his was just so hurtful, and I've never understood WHY he treats me like that? I mean, I can literally walk into his house with my suitcase, give lots of hugs and kisses to his children and wife, and he will sit in the living room and not even acknowledge my presence. I've told him that I feel hurt by his behavior, and he tells me I'm too sensitive and accuses me of making it "all about me". (This is his FAVORITE thing to tell me, btw, that I think everything is all about me. I hear it from him on a regular basis.) He has been a bully, a brute, a controller... it seemed that once a year or so for the past 20 years, we would have a physical confrontation. And that is a leftover dysfunctional behavior on his part from our childhood, where he did "beat me up" pretty frequently. We kids raised ourselves, pretty much. We had a completely absentee father and a single mother who worked a lot, and even when home she spent her time with her life's distractions of compulsive shopping/hoarding, and church activities to the nth. So we kids grew up, really, without parenting at all. And so older bro's brutality and cruelty to me, which in a "normal home" would have been stopped by a parent, just went on into, literally, adulthood, and continues, at times, to this very day.
And he was very cruel, physically and mentally, all throughout childhood and high school. I really believed, based on what he told me about myself, that I was pretty worthless... that no man (boy) would or could ever really like me or love me, I was unattractive, I was too skinny, I was a geek, etc. He was extremely manipulative and extremely selfish. He has also been very arrogant his entire life. He seems to truly believe he is an exceptionally gifted, intelligent, and talented man, naturally better somehow than other people. His wife, who was his childhood sweetheart, seems (to me) to be almost unnaturally supportive and tolerant of him, and while I'm happy that they have a good marriage, to me it makes so much sense why he picked her for a wife... she's one of the few women in the world that I can see putting up with all of his arrogance and allowing him to just "rule" over her in every way.
The day of my GMs wake was the last physical fight my brother started with me. He was completely out of line, he thought I did or said something that didn't happen, and so he called me into a side bedroom away from others, shut the door behind him, and proceeded to get "in my face" and hiss at me how he was going to "show me how evil he could be." I was completely blindsided by his sudden temper, as I always am... he seems to just flash this violence towards me out of nowhere... and he barricaded me in the bedroom while I cried and yelled at him to let me leave. I tried to push him out of the way of the door but he wouldn't let me out, standing over me, trying to intimidate me with his much bigger size, and kept telling me what a piece of sh*t I was, and all this other just mean and derogatory stuff. And he has a REGULAR pattern of doing this kind of thing with me, even now, as I am 38 and he is now 40. It seems he has mellowed some as he has grown as a father to his four children, but my brother still views me - for reasons truly unknown to me - as his "competition" which must be crushed at times...
At least this is my take on it.
I choose to apologize to my brother even if I've done nothing wrong, if apologizing will avoid an argument. I try to act "submissive" and "subservient" around him... this seems to be what he seeks from me. And the detachment is helping a lot because now, I don't even seem to get all the whirling, confusing emotions that have surrounded my relationship with him all my life... now, I feel a bit more like I can just choose to see him as the idiot he is (lol), and just let him be. He still tries to pick fights but I've learned to simply NOT GO THERE with him.
Thanks, Margeaux, for asking me about my bro and giving me a chance to put some of this stuff into words. I find, for me, its really helpful to write down the concise ideas about how I feel, and how I view family relationships. Otherwise, it just seems like a big icky muddle in my mind.
(((hugs))) to all, hope everyone is having a lovely Sunday!
She is fine when my brother is here....but when I'm alone with her here...she becomes combative. We historically have never had a positive relationship. But it's not fair for my brother to be here all the time, he has his own place. He doesn't realize that him being her makes her calm. I have been away for 30 plus years. My brother has lived in the same city with her. So there is that factor. And, whenever she talks to her sister long distance that just causes more combative behavior because her sister has Dementia too but tells my mother that she can drive and do whatever she wants. So I have resorted to turning the ringer off of the phone in her bedroom and turning off the answering machine just to avoid the drama of her sister stirring the pot.
My brother is in denial and doesn't understand why she blows up when he goes and is fine when he's here. Clearly I'm a trigger for her combative behavior although I pay all the bills, do all the shopping, make sure all of her meds are refilled and picked up, put them in the pill box, clean, do laundry cook, etc.
My brother will take her out for rides when she feels up to it.
I basically have not relationship with her and keep to myself. Just one conversation with me could cause her to snap so I don't want to take that chance. I have to take care of myself .
I'm at the point where if she takes her other meds she takes them, if she doesn't she doesn't. There is only so much I can do. I have put Aricept in with her morning meds until I hear from her Drs. hopefully they will contact me Monday. This all happened Friday evening.
I will ask about the Namenda but she is so sensitive to drugs she notices any change that makes her feel different. So if the neurologist, I don't know how we are going to introduce her to it. If it's a different color she will notice it and take all the pills except that one esp if it makes her "feel different"
Thanks for your feed back. She wouldn't take it but sporadically for a week, so I don't know if it was working or not. I called her Dr's and told them she threw out the pills. I asked her primary care doctor to approve a home nurse to come in and draw blood because she typically get's her blood work once a month with her monthly visit to her doctor. I always ask for a UTI test because that's how all of this started when she was hospitalized last year.
So far each month she has not had a UTI but she has not had a blood test in 2 months. So....I'm not sure if the Exelon was too much or just had horrible effects on her or if it's something else. But getting her to go into the Doctor is so HARD! So I have alerted all of her doctors but she needs to get lab work to rule out something like a UTI.
Her Neurologist mentioned Namenda once. What are the side effects? I'm giving her Aricept while waiting for Neurologist to call. I have no idea as to what to do. She is also on an anti depressant Lexapro.
Any feedback on Namenda would be greatly appreciated.
I'm glad that you took a look at EFT. It is a good technique, works for me.
My sister, as a child was always more the rebel than I ever was during that time.
Add to this, that our mother conquered and divided the siblings, and even my dad participated in this. Both my parents played favorites. Even though, my mom and my sister had lots of tension between them, ....she was acknowledged for many things such as intelligence and beauty way more than I was.
On top of all of that, my sister is an extremely jealous person, by nature and also her birth sign....guess which one she is?
My sister even as a kid had this way of domineering a variety of situations.
She's a year younger than me, and I started to behave in certain ways, that were not assertive, when I really should have been. Why? I wanted to be liked.
Yes, the people pleaser syndrome. I know that when we don't get validated, and especially when we are children, as in my own case, I was in charge of the three other siblings for two working parents. So I get it that if a child doesn't get what they should be getting from a parent, we start to try to compensate in other ways, by seeking some approval, acceptance from others, be that a sibling, or another family member. My sister has always been critical, and judgmental too, so many things I was always about, or doing always came under some weird scrutiny of my sister's. But when I became a teen, that changed dramatically. I finally grew out of and tired of seeking approval by someone who after some analysis....I thought, My sister can have a really cruel side to herself. By then....I'd heard from enough friends too who invariably would complain to me about some unkindness, my sister had committed. Later, as we became adults,
I by now really changed my whole attitude about my manipulative sister, and we really went our separate ways, so to say. I just could not relate to her at all.
Part of that was the realization, that although some of us would like to see the good in our brothers, sisters or even friends......there really has to be something tangible coming from their end too, in order for this to happen.
If all your brother does is berate you, he is the one with the problem......and there's really no fixing that. They have to be the ones to change some of this, then maybe they'd deserve to be admired..
If I may ask, does he criticize you for the way you are caregiving for your father?
Take care,
Much Love & Light! Margeaux
I want to wish you a Happy Birthday.
May your year be wonderful, and bestow many blessings!
Yummy....prawns, herbs and roasted vegetables.
I hope you had a great one with Gary.
Much Love & Light! Margeaux
Karen, sounds like your mom wants out and is trying to find ways to get kicked out. Or finding ways to get you to visit her? It’s definitely an attention-getting behavior. Well, just continue as you are doing. Congrats on being a mother-in-law! And it sure helps when you love the bride! =)
Powerof1, you are sooo fortunate that your mom’s attitude changed about NH. Yeah, go for that vacation and enjoy yourself.
Gladimhere- you are not the only one that I have read on this site who have a sibling in the counseling profession. I remembered last year, the very first time I read a poster who couldn’t believe her sibling is a counselor and did not help at all with the caregiving. Did not offer any help –physically or financially. It just bogs the mind, doesn’t it?
Hi Margeaux, I hope the stresses have toned down a bit now?
Sharynmarie, I enjoyed your story of your mom being a determined escape artist! And that she’s actually up there dancing a storm. She’s definitely beginning to enjoy her stay but still trying to make her great escape.
I am glad to hear your mother is responding to the Exelon pills. I am very happy with the Namenda because it seems to have stabilized the progression for the time being. My mom would take off the patch too!!
We feel my mother is "fighting" the effects of the Excelon (it's only been a week) because she does not like the way it makes her feel. Almost like a baby fighting sleep. But we do see a difference in her combativeness. It's better or doesn't last as long if she takes the Excelon. The problem is....getting her to take the pill. She would rip off the patch in a heart beat :-(
We feel my mother is "fighting" the effects of the Excelon (it's only been a week) because she does not like the way it makes her feel. Almost like a baby fighting sleep. But we do see a difference in her combativeness. It's better or doesn't last as long if she takes the Excelon. The problem is....getting her to take the pill. She would rip off the patch in a heart beat :-(
It is hard to have those anniversaries come up, especially about a father.
Mine has been gone now going on 12 yrs., and every March 3'd, I go through this.
He must have been a wonderful guy.
So your son got married? Congratulations! Well this is good news, because I remember you posted something about your mom having I think it was a very indifferent attitude about it. Yes, it's less work. It's great to hear that you really love your new DIL.
Much Love & Light! Margeaux
On the conversation about husbands at home - God love them - but mine just retired last year - and I work from home....I pine for just an hour a day alone =).
Joan - please take care of yourself - you did take a really bad fall! The allergy to the meds really don't help. Lots and lots of water!
Thanks all - Happy Friday!
Karen