Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
I think your husband doesn't know enough about dementia and how it breaks a person's brain. - impaired short-term memory means he will have to "correct" your Dad over and over again, like Groundhog's Day. It won't stick, no matter how many times he tries. Does he really want to spend his time doing that? Your husband may be better off just redirecting the conversation to something else or distracting your Dad with something else. Or, he can ignore it and pretend he's getting a phone call and walk out of the room. - dementia robs people of their ability to use reason and logic, so trying to get them to "see" an error in their thinking will be futile, and will make them feel bad about something they don't understand and can't control. Maybe your husband's issue is that he sees himself in your Dad and it is unnerving him, thinking that one day that might be him who is being patronized. It's not that uncommon a response to something that is heartbreaking to watch and difficult to adjust to. Also consider that if your Dad lives with you, your husband maybe doesn't feel like he can tell you he secretly doesn't really like this arrangement; maybe he doesn't feel like he's your priority anymore; maybe he mourns or resents the loss of his privacy. These are all things that have been expressed on this forum a multitude of times by spouses who live with their declining inlaws. Many spouses feel like they'd be the "bad guy" for wanting the inlaw to move to a facility. If he wants "proof" about the benefits of therapeutic fibs, show him this thread and many other posts on this forum. There was recently a post about a Mom in a MC facility who thought a doll was a real baby and became extremely upset when the staff didn't treat it like it was her real baby. People with dementia can no longer bring their minds to a place of contentment and peace. Medication can only do so much. My own Aunt with advanced dementia thought a stuffed rainbow-colored llama was her baby, and we all went along with it. It didn't cost us anything to do it, and the gain was that it made her happy, kept her busy in a good way and gave her a sense of purpose and worth as a Mother.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

No matter what husband says to dad, your father will remain in his own world. It is a kind world, a place where he finds comfort, and there's nothing wrong with that. Dad won't remember for long what husband says to him, probably.

I'm sorry you're having this problem with your husband. He has for some reason decided to be bullheaded and inconsiderate of you and dad. Perhaps he is feeling that he doesn't get enough of your attention because you're so concentrated on dad. Maybe he's like a child who resents another child coming along and capturing all of mommy's attention.

I can't tell you what to do about that, but I know what I'd do. I'd disengage a bit from husband and stop talking about dad, dad, dad. Taking care of an elder with dementia tends to narrow our outlook on everything. Nothing else seems important sometimes. So I get it. I've done it.

This is how taking care of parents with dementia can change a couple's marriage forever. Just sayin'.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

If you have Netflix, I suggest sitting dh down and watching Black Mirror: San Junipero.

The spoiler, which you shouldn’t divulge, is that this episode features nursing homes giving residents a neural link that allows them to be transported to whatever time and generation they wish. And as a protagonist said, “This is real. How can you say it’s not real?” And the viewer gets exactly how this is real to them being that the story is from their pov.

The point being is that your father has retreated into an alternate comforting reality that comforts him as his brain continues to die.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
NewOnAnOldRoad May 11, 2025
WOW!...I have to Ponder this.
...Im not crazy about "therapeutic lies" either and I am new to this forum and read about the "medical reasoning" behind them. What has been asked and stated here has certainly got my attention. Thank you.
(1)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter