Follow
Share
Read More
News flash...being POA does not give you power over her decisions unless she is deemed mentally incompetent. Your mom has rights and can do what she wants. My mom is 96 and had been living in a high rated assisted living facility for 4 years. She moved into an apartment on her own despite the entire family, doctor's, pastor and friends advising her against it! She has so many medical problems and of course, needs outside help to come in which now costs her more per month than living at the facility did. She will run out of money within 2 years and suffer the consequences. I have had to give up trying to control the situation as my own health and my marriage have suffered trying to fight this battle. Mom says she is happy and I see her once a week. So be it!
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Whatshedidat95
Report
TouchMatters Sep 12, 2025
I don't understand how this post applies or supports the writer.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
No.
I think you already know the answer and are looking for confirmation.
Go with your gut on this! You are POA!

Thank the niece for her offer and let her know that she is not in the best position to provide the cares your mother needs. A SNF is where she needs to be.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report

[The niece] you write: "She has a track record of lying, stealing and cheating others to gain material possessions and large sums of money.) I fear that Mom will move out of the SNF and then I will have a very difficult time getting her back in or at the very least locating another top-notch facility."

You have addressed your own answer.

As you are legally responsible, not only is this a very tentative, potentially, if not probably, an unstable living situation, your mom, in your words "also has cognitive decline with delusions, visions, etc. and is not rational..." and she is in her 80s with top notch care where you can be an integral part of overseeing her care, and visit / support her regularly.

I do not see any ... reason or solid basis for making a decision to move your mother. She will not be content no matter where she is. Mother is in a fantasy of how it used to be.

She is unable to cognitively evaluate the potential situation / outcome / care / lack of care / being left alone / the possible stealing ... and on and on. It is up to you to make these decisions for her that are in her best welfare - that she cannot make herself.

She is in the best living situation she could be in and that is a blessing and a half. How many of us could say our parents / elder family members are in a housing development like that ? (none to very few). Or that we might be able to be in a living situation like that when we need it ? (very few).

Don't look a gift horse in the mouth. I think that's the phrase. In other words, be VERY VERY ... and very grateful that your mom has the best of care now and that you are close enough to visit regularly.

If I were you, I would (try to) focus on more one-on-one interactions with your mom - with volunteers, perhaps friends. Try to engage her more to feel connected - to herself and her environment. Perhaps a medication change could help her. I appreciate you taking good care of her.

Lastly, how much interaction does her niece have with her now? If possible, I would limit that now since it is a trigger for your mom wanting to move in a potentially unstable household. The goal is keep your mom as calm and emotionally centered/stable as possible. This means telling her what will calm her down or give her hope. Perhaps you can say, "we're working on it" - leave that door open in her mind... give her hope to manifest her fantasies, while you equally focus on keeping her as engaged as possible. Give / get her a massage or regular massages if this might help relax her. Even a shoulder rub, hand, or foot massage helps. It is the touch connection that matters.

Gena / Touch Matters
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to TouchMatters
Report
LoniG1 Sep 12, 2025
Its always nice to read your words of wisdom i absolutely appreciate you.
(1)
Report
After years of reading here on the forum, I will say that this never ends well. Don't agree to it.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to graygrammie
Report

It doesn't sound like a good situation.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Nan333
Report

This sounds like a no-brainer to me. NO, NO, NO. She’s in a 5 star facility now. Leave well enough alone. Please don’t do it.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to JColl7
Report

Quite clearly, no, you shouldn't allow her to move anywhere. She is well looked after where she is and that is the main responsibility you have as her POA. It is not to keep her happy, which is an impossible task anyway.

My mother was similar and wanted to move from a great AL to an inferior one where she thought she would be happy. I said no. She didn't like it but that's OK. Your job is to look after her "needs", not her "wants". You know perfectly well even if she did move she wouldn't be happy for long.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to golden23
Report

I am glad that I came across your post today as I am currently going thru a very similar situation with my Mom wanting to move. I only have a medical POA for her but it applies here as the move would not be in her best interest medically according to her Physicians. She is not yet ready for memory care but when it’s time the transition within the same facility will be easier on her. My Mom is 91 with dementia and persistent delusions and paranoia. She wants to relocate back to where she lived some 50 years ago and farther away from me. She currently lives in a high end assisted living facility that is A+, but has decided that she would be happier going back to a place in time where she “last remembers feeling happy and feeling safe.” In her mental state, she will not be happy anywhere she goes. I’ve been told by her Doctors that seniors with dementia do not transition well to unfamiliar surroundings. They said that In most studies, the health effects of the relocation of older adults suffering from dementia showed a decline in physical, mental, behavioural, and functional well-being. The most recurring effect was a higher level of stress, which is more problematic for patients with dementia. I have a letter from her Psychiatrist and GP stating that she is incompetent. I have felt so guilty at preventing her from doing what she believes would make her happy, but as someone aptly pointed out in another comment, your responsibility is not to make her happy but to ensure that she is properly cared for and safe. Her happiness is a bonus. Mine is currently socializing during meals and “happy hour”, going on group outings, playing bingo, crosswords, book club, etc. and she has friends. I’d suggest that you request that same letter of incapacity from your Mom’s Dr.’s (it takes 2) and inform the facility that you are enforcing your proxy so that she will not be discharged, as it’s a safety issue. She will be mad and may even disown you, as mine has, but it’s in her best interest to stay where she is. I hate this disease. Best of luck to you both as you navigate this heartbreaking disease process.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to CDunks
Report

No.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to jemfleming
Report

MissGypsy: While the niece may be well intentioned, it may be too much of a daunting task not to mention your mother needs medical professionals offered at the SNF.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Llamalover47
Report

Just because careful with your demands. Your are POA which is great However Mom still has rights its called personal choice. Do not tell facility to ban niece or not allow phone calls as that can bit you in the rear. Its called isolation and that can be a felony for you and the facility. Even if you go for conservatorship thru the courts. They will still allow her personal choice, not engaging with other residents, not wanting showers, she has a right to receive phone calls, visitors of her choice, even going to lunch. Even if you feel its not in her best interest. I have seen family member just get out of prison for drugs, fraud, assult and so on, and mom still has a right to visit. Now if for some reason. Mom fears that person then its her right to say NO not today. There are other ways to nip that niece in the bud. You need to fight fire with fire. Put the niece in her place. Pretty sure niece has no clue what the law is so use it againt her. You can tell her she is jeprody moms health,safety, and well being and you will take legal action against her. If she does not stop. She has roommates and no place for mom to have privacy and the 24/7 nursing care that she needs. Nor the income it would cost for the care. As for mom you are doing your best and its by no means an easy job. I gave my mom my reasons for her not being able to go with my sister and she needed to stay at this facility. She said I HATE YOU. I said thats ok mom cause I love you more. Its ok for mom to be upset and even call you names and even hate you. Give her a day or 2 and she wont remember her words. Just remember this. when you can look in the mirror and know your doing whats best out of love for your mom. That makes you the best damn daughter out there. Can't ask for anything better than that.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to LoniG1
Report

What would be the sleeping arrangements in the small two-bedroom residence? Your mom would be sharing a bedroom with the niece? Would she have her own bed, and what size would the bed be? How many people would she be sharing a bathroom with? Is the place accessible with her walker? How would she get to places? Would she even be able to get out of and back into the house (stairs, etc.)? How would she manage while the niece is traveling for weeks at a time. Just thinking of questions you might ask her if she persists.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to MG8522
Report

You have POA and your mother has dementia. The answer to her leaving the good place she's in has to be no. Is it possible that your mother will "turn" on you which happens so often with dementia? Is it possible that she will disown you and never want to see you again? These things are possible and this is where strength and love comes in. You want to do what's best and right for your mother and that is leaving her where she is. What's right isn't always easy and sometimes doesn't make everyone happy.

I'm so sorry you're in such a difficult position. This is a good forum to get support from others who know what you're going through. Good luck.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report

Firstly, I hope that this top notch facility is paid for from your mum's own pocket and not yours. You need to save your money for your own old age.

If your mum is deemed competent, then you can't stop her moving in with your cousin. However, if she is deemed incompetent, and seeing as you have POA, I would say no. This would be an inappropriate living arrangement, as the accommodation would be overcrowded and not set up for someone with cognitive impairment.

You know that this would cause you more problems in the future, so put your foot down now. Use your POA and the inadequacy of the living arrangements to oppose this.

If you are funding your mum's living arrangements and care - STOP! Your mum should have the care and accommodation she can afford. No more, no less.

If your mum is giving you a hard time, then manage her care from a distance, with short visits. You can't change how she feels about where she lives, so don't even try.

Take care of yourself and your own health. Good luck!
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to MiaMoor
Report

Like others on this platform, your question begs another: Why do you need outside approval to do what is against your wishes as the holder of the PoA? I sense some animosity/inconvenience issues between you and said niece which, in my family, would be called my cousin…. Have a talk with yourself first then, if your mother insists:
1. Get the niece to enter into a contract in which you set out the terms of care (and list EVERYTHING).
2. Agree to the monthly rate and food allowance (as part of the contract).
3. Your mother should have her own room, bed and toilet facility (part of the contract) where she can remove herself from the chaos of 4 adults and various pets in a 2 bedroom residence.
4. When the niece travels, define the sort of person required to monitor the household (read “your mother”) and put a price tag on it (so that the help fund doesn’t become a slush fund).
5. Contractually stipulate the niece’s responsibility to find your mother a place equal to or better than where she is now when your mother, or her niece, or the other residents, get fed up with the situation and it all goes to hell in a hand basket - it will.
5. You see where I’m going with this so extend the contract as you see fit.
6. And, finally, and most importantly, get both your mother and her niece to sign this (or you sign for your mother) in front of a notary and have it stamped with an official seal.

Your mother’s niece will run for the hills and you will be doing your mother’s bidding.

Good luck!
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Whodat
Report
CaregiverL Sep 14, 2025
Dear Who,
These rules will all be broken day 1
(2)
Report
Absolutely not. I have been my husbands 24-hr caregiver for 8 years and truthfully, I was broken the 1st or 2nd year. People that do not do this do not understand the full life commitment it requires or just are not performing it to the level it requires. Trained staff knows and also gets 16 hours off a day. Many days I'd pay a lot of money for just 2 hours off. It is a terrible disease and not meant for casual involvement or dedication even though the memories of that relationship may be special. As deterioration occurs, the patient is no longer who you once knew. Leave her where the care is great and be thankful for it, irrelevent what she thinks.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to tsekscinski
Report
JeanLouise Sep 15, 2025
Caregiving your spouse is absolute purgatory. We're in a miserable club.
(0)
Report
Absolutely NOT!!!!! Your mom will decline more, start falling because that’s what dementia does…& need more, not less care! If mom misses niece, have niece come visit mom where she is…Hugs 🤗
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to CaregiverL
Report

You know the answer—no way. Pose the question to mom’s doc who will also say “no way” and then you will have medical authority to decline this nightmare scenario. Even if all parties are well meaning, they have no clue what it will be like caring for your mom, who will only need more care down the line. And it will all fall on you to figure out a solution.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to WendyElaine
Report

You have the POA. No way would I allow this to happen.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Scampie1
Report

Oh.....I'm straight out hearing you answer your own question. My first question was going to be what you thought the motivation for the nieces offer is but you answered that. Based on what you shared I can't see that move benefiting anyone and what happens when the niece says I've had enough and wants her out??? I'll tell you honestly, any conversations you have today with someone approaching dementia will be gradually forgotten over time.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to TH2Os5
Report

I doubt you can "let" any action by these two. The authority is not yours. I agree it's a terrible decision to give up and A#1 facility for this pipe dream. Ultimately, it's beyond your influence. My best guess; if the move happens, detach completely. They're the ones that will be holding the bag.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to JeanLouise
Report

This question was asked over a week ago. The OP has not responded at all and there are 50 responses. Would be nice to know what OPs decision was.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

Absolutely not! You have POA which means you DO have the final say here. My cousin said she'd take my mother in to live with her, too, in a 3 story home when mom had advanced dementia and was in a wheelchair full time! These people have no clue what they're doing or offering. And my cousin was full of baloney in the first place. Talk is cheap.

Its your job as POA to keep mom safe and cared for where she's at right now, vs a pie in the sky promise elsewhere. It's a no brainer, imo.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

No, absolutely not! She is where she needs to be. Her niece will not put up with taking care of her very long, and she most likely has an ulterior motive - who would volunteer to do that? Your Mom is settled - don't turn everything upside down and create a disaster for her and for yourself.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Lylii1
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter