Follow
Share

I don't know if this is just my Dad's personality or if it has something to do with Alzheimer's. He tells lots of stories from either high school, college or during the WWII war years. Many have incidents where someone in the story that he knows personally has some sort of accident or misfortune. Each time he tells these stories he laughs at the incident. Now this could be "we can look back on this and laugh" but it doesn't feel right. Has anyone else experienced this with the ones they care for?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.

20 Answers

Most
Helpful Newest
First Oldest
First
Susan26. I would not bother challenging your FIL while I do admit laughing at a murder is rough and completely out of whack. Have you spoken to your FIL's doctor? I can't speak to my Dad's doctors as he has revoked the POA. That said, I tried to gently challenge my Dad and he goes blank or says whatever the incident was wasn't that bad. Like others have said this may be due to a personality defect or a defensive mechanism as I believe he is scared and laughing at others may make him feel better. Very sad.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
ThirdKid,
Don't feel ashamed, I imagine we all snap back from time to time. It is tough to get berated much of the time with grace and kindness. No, there are times we just cannot win.
Take care!
Lisa
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Hi,
I have been seeing on TV ads that talk about inappropriate laughter (and crying jags)- it is for a drug to help with this condition that they called PBA- Pseudo-Bulbar Affect (sp?). I found a link about this PBA on a stroke site. Maybe this is what is going on with some of the elders.

It talks about how this condition can happen with all kinds of dementia related diseases and/or brain injuries.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
This is a really interesting thread, I don't think I have ever seen this question but it does resonate with me. My Mother seems to only light up now when she hears of another persons misfortune. All of the good stuff she is really not interested in but if there is a tragedy she is all ears. I have pondered this and think it is their way of still feeling "young" or "better" than others. Guess it is just a defense mechanism but it is so irritating and annoying.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
This has been a very interesting and informative thread. I deal w/ a borderline personality person, and she has some similar behavior to these narcissitic ones many of you have mentioned. I agree w/ Alwayslearning, that much of it stems from deep feelings of inferiority and fear. They cover it up by laughing at others, or trying to bring others down to (or below) their level in an attempt to elevate themselves in their own mind. They have to do this because to be as low as they really feel deep inside would be unbearable to live with. It's a sad and sorry way to live, and it is hard to tolerate.....but to know the reason why and where it comes from can sometimes help. From what I understand, it's a living hell, really, for the person who is like this, yet they don't display that for others to see. It's not and excuse for this behavior, but an understanding of why, which can help to deal with it more compassionately, or like Seven said, "turn a deaf ear!" That's best.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
my fil is the same. the other day i was telling my husband an unbelivably tragic story ... my clients entire family were recently murdered in the most shocking event. my fil started to laugh and chortle with glee. i have noticed he does it whenever there is some bad experience or hard luck story. we were all completely shocked with his response.
the next time he does it though, i will challenge him and ask him exactly what he finds so funny about other peoples tragedies.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
When in a dark mood, my sibling laughs while deriding another's thoughts and feelings. I swear there's two personalities: the nice one and the a**h**e one. Won't that be fun when at 80 yrs old!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Wondering if there is something in their background that brings this out?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
It is worth noting that a loss of empathy and inappropriate reactions to other people's pain, loss, or misfortune is a particular hallmark of frontal temporal dementia (FTD).

My father has been diagnosed with this dementia (though I am relieved that so far, he has not exhibited any of the inappropriate social behaviors or decrease in empathy that some people with the disease experience). But while I was researching the disease, I read stories of FTD patients laughing and telling jokes at funerals, mocking people in tears, and becoming otherwise unable to connect, relate to, or empathize with other people ... or, therefore, to reach out to or comfort them.

I don't know if Alzheimer's similarly affects the lobes of the brain that support empathy, but of course, it is possible for a dementia patient to have more than one dementia disease process going on ... so if the person seems increasingly to be unaware of (or uncaring about or possibly even pleased about) the problems of others, keep in mind that it may be another symptom of brain atrophy.

And, of course, it is possible (as indicated in other replies here) for a dementia patient to have a mean or sociopathic streak that pre-dates the dementia.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
This also hit home with me about my Mom. But it's strange how Mom will laugh at something really strange but when we take pictures at family functions she puts a "prune" face on and will not change it for anything.
My niece brought her grand baby up (she lives 2 States South) for 5th generation family pictures and I could not believe how Mom would not smile for any of the pictures. I even tried to tweek them on a program I had and could not make them right. My niece was so upset over how Mom acted...as well as the rest of us.
Mom has always been the type that needs to be the center of attention and telling Non Funny events I guess puts her in the center.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
StressedStPete, I love it when you speak of making your fathers last years comfortable, safe and peaceful. I'm trying to do that, too! I think we all are... BTW, I worked in a pharmacyfor years, and my older patients were often very self-centered. They yell about the government, their medscosting $1.00 more than they used to, they abuse the staff and complain to management when we politely attempt to field their questions, even when we are about to close. It seems like old age brings out the worst behavior in some people and they heap it on the heads of people who can't fight back.
On my worst days, I snap back at my mother. She really is rude and thoughtless at times. I am then ashamed of myself. Apparently, I can't win!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
To StressSt.Pete, my mother also puts on the charm for about three or four days and then it breaks down to her normal "mean" personality.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
I am relieved (as strange as that sounds) to know that other people have experienced a parent laughing at other people's misfortunes. My mother has been doing this all my life and I have come to the defense of people that I don't even know. I have even thought of her doing this as a bit evil in her personality.
I only brought home a couple of friends while in school and didn't realize that my mother was insulting them because I was so conditioned to insults. I just knew that nobody ever wanted to hang out with me afterwards.
It took me until nearly age 60 to come to realize all this abusive behavior.
In my case, it is my mother laughing and seeming to enjoy that other people are suffering especially when it comes to finances or women being murdered. Its crazy, but I have heard her blame the women for being in the wrong place or with the wrong person and that is what they deserve.
Has anybody else out there on the forum experienced a parent blaming a female victim for their own murder?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Thank you all, you have all offered insight into this behavior. I don't have much of a history with my father, I have not had much contact with him over the years. I left home at 18 and I am now 58. He has been married 3 times so he hadn't done much to be involved in his first family. I was apparently the only place he could come to but I agree in both ways that it is narcissism as well as fear. I have a suspicion that he has always been somewhat like this and his disease has made it worse. Having him insert himself into my life and his brother and sister's lives was baffling but here he is and I am trying my best to make his final years comfortable, safe and peaceful. Happiness is probably too much to hope for as being a "Grumpy Gus" seems to be the norm, at least with me. When others are around he puts on the charm! Thanks again for letting me know I am not alone in dealing with this behavior.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
My mother laughs this hollow, empty and unfunny laugh at the end of practically every sentence. It's very annoying. She's especially glad to laugh at me. It's a lifelong personality trait.
I'm guessing that she wants to appear to be fun and lighthearted, even tho she is not. Like she's trying to be in the in crowd. Or, maybe to feel included and sometimes she laughs so inappropriately....ugh.
I have to try to see her as a desperate, childish person when she does this. I have to withhold my feelings of annoyance. I have to be the grown up. I don't like it.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
I agree with seven13 that underneath all that obnoxiousness is woundedness. I would also put it this way: underneath all that obnoxiousness is fear. It is all about projecting scary stuff or bad feelings onto other people, in one of a couple different ways. Such as (1) if I judge everybody else and make comments about them, (a) I am getting the jump on being judged myself, and (b) I am convincing myself and everybody else that comments are ok. (2) If I can make light of bad things happening to other people then (a) I can be comforted that bad things aren't happening to me and (b) if bad things happen to me then I'm proving I can make light of them. So.... judging others, commenting on others, sneering or laughing at others' misfortunes is about fear of being judged, fear of being commented on, fear of misfortune. Twisted, eh? But that's how it works. This is happening on such a deep level that not only they would never want to admit it but they don't even really know it so they probably couldn't admit it even if they wanted to.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Agreed, beautifulsc.....it seems like "schadenfreude" ( the delight in the misfortunes of others) is a huge part of narcissism. I think it makes them feel better to say to themselves, no, this isn't happening to ME, it's someone else, oh aren't I lucky. They ARE negative and self-serving and these habits an patterns arent going to change, especially as they age. They get older, they get worse.
My mother when she was hospitalized over the last ten years, has made terrible comments in front of people especially nurses etc. who are trying to help her. She thinks it's smart to comment on people's height, ethnicity etc. and does it out loud to make sure they, and others, will hear it. She has never had any boundaries or filters so you don't know what's coming next which is part of her strategy so she can get the upper hand. (and for shock value).
Reading on here about narcissism has helped me a lot. What you'll find is that under a cocoon of smart remarks, grandiose ideas about themselves, major attitude and huge self-entitlement are very insecure "wounded" people -- but they are just clever enough to hide in that and it allows them to carry out their sabotage against others.
These people, to others, are the very best people in the world. I constantly get phone calls telling me what a wonderful person she is -- but they don't have to live with her and her sarcastic remarks about everything on the planet!!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Yep, sounds familiar. Both of my elderly parents delight in others misfortunes. They talk badly about people who lose their homes and/or jobs. And my pompous-ass father (who has been retired for 40 years) claims people are lazy who lose their jobs and can't find another one. He retired after working 20 years in the military, so I am sure he didn't pay into SS as much as he has gotten out of it. So, they live very well on tax payer dollars now! These are bitter old narcissistic people who think the universe revolves around them. It makes me wonder how my parents, who have a wonderful life, can be so negative and self-serving.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
my dad was just born to gloat at the misfortunes of others and it only got worse when he got older and demented. im learning to forgive. forgive myself for detesting the sob that is..
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
I think your first question should be "is this something new?" or has he always been like this? My mother delights in regaling me with tales of people's unfortunate, and sometimes, gross medical stories, or family issues, which are, of course, none of her business. She also enjoys the reaction she gets from telling people about child and animal abuse stories she has heard about in the news. Her favourite thing is to bring these up at mealtimes or family gatherings when she can get the biggest effect!
She also exhibits a very strange and twisted sense of humour if someone else is having a bad day, is upset, or is bothered by something......I think it is one of their defense mechanisms (it's not happening to me, thank goodness! so why should I care?)
If he has always done this then I think it is part of a personality disorder, as in my mother's case. But if he has just started doing this as a part of an Alzheimer's diagnoses then it is part and parcel of that.
The best way to handle it is to change the subject and ignore their glee in the misfortune or accident. If they don't get the reaction they want they go on to something else. It is very disturbing at times but sometimes it helps to pretend that they are a "stranger" -- and not your parent. (ie, you would react differently if a stranger was doing it where as you would if it is your parent).
In my mother's case she always did this, there is a narcissistic component to it, and I think she just liked the attention and reactions she would get, and it gave her importance to repeat these things. Now I just turn a deaf ear!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.

Recent Questions


Popular Questions


Related Questions

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter