Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Do you have an organization in your town that helps people find senior care. In the Tampa Florida area we have a small company called Simply Advocates. These ladies know every large to small ALF and memory care in our area. When we got to this very same place you are at (ALF he had been at for 2 years said they could no longer accommodate my 95 year old Dad due to transfer issues( from Wheelchair to commode and to bed) These ladies helped us find a small ALF with 6 residents and they were wonderful. A godsend. But see if you can find a company like that in your area. You don't pay them, the facility does.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I haven't seen this detail, in all the discussion -- how long does it take your mother to eat her dinner, if someone is sitting with her? Is it different when it's you, as opposed to when it's the staff?

In some states at least, the state sets a minimum number of minutes that mealtime at a facility has to last, to make sure that residents who need help with meals or who eat on their own, but slowly, are not rushed through the process. One facility I'm familiar with had their shift change shortly after dinner, and there was a lot of pressure on the staff there to get the meal and cleanup done by the time their shift ended so they could leave on time and so the next shift would not be arriving needing to finish that process. In retrospect, I would have gone to the management and if necessary the ombudsman to complain that some residents were being short-changed at meal time.

Is your mother's facility even abiding by the state law? You can look up the law and regulations online If your mother needs, say, 15 minutes, then it should be on the staff to find that time at least for dinner. If it's an hour of one-on-one time that she needs, that's different. There should also be a patients bill of rights or something similar posted in the facility.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
ShirleyDot Nov 16, 2025
He said it could take up to an hour in one post. That's a long time and is fuel for the speculation that she is simply trying to keep her son from leaving as long as possible.
(1)
Report
You can’t always get everything you want. What do you want most – to prolong M’s life, or to avoid personal liability if she starves herself to death? Your W’s suggestion about moving away was around liability, so that’s what she understood was important to you. If that is most important, one attorney’s comments are not enough for such a complicated situation. To protect yourself consider:
1) Contacting APS, and getting comments in writing.
2) Contacting your local member of parliament and any other local dignitory, so ask for their advice. Document that too.
3) Seeing more than one attorney, and seeing any free legal service you can find. Document the advice.

Even if what you get is ‘nobody knows’, that’s better protection than simply making up your own mind.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I’ve read the OP and maybe a third of the long thread of answers here, and my impulse is to try to understand better by “unpacking” a couple of ideas.

The first is the idea of a game. Implicitly, in this context, the idea that OP’s mom is playing a game would seem objectionable—but why? Games are play, and isn’t play fun and healthy? Maybe we’re thinking of a game as Manipulation. Maybe calling it a “game” means we think that the person is making choices that are arbitrary, disrespectful, inappropriate, or inconsiderate. Maybe we are feeling some stress, so we think, how can someone ELSE be having “fun” that involves us, but that isn’t fun for us? It isn’t fair.

So another way of framing this behavior of only eating when someone else is there might be: Communication. Whether or not OP’s mom is conscious of her message, there’s something being communicated by the behavior.

We are social beings, and as the OP told us, they used to eat in a familial way growing up. So when there’s no family feeling of warmth and connection, maybe it just doesn’t feel like her life to her. It becomes unrecognizable to her as a meal. In some societies the elders voluntarily go out on the mountain to die. I’m not suggesting that’s the answer here, but, pulling away from social ties is both a sign of loosening ties in preparation for ultimate passing, and also, a feedback loop where the person’s community is conveying by how they interact—or fail to interact—what that person means to the group, the value they have. And as people get older and older, their value does tend to diminish as other community priorities take over.

So maybe instead of Game, we can think of it as a kind of feedback loop, or negotiation, or communication, by which OP’s mom is signaling that, without the warmth of human interaction, her life doesn’t have as much value TO HER as it once did—and no one is to blame for that. We can’t always meet others’ needs. And the OP is still struggling to figure out how much value he places on his mom’s life and wellbeing, in the face of everything else going on.

I still remember the last time my FIL, who lived with us during his end-stage Parkinson’s disease, came into the kitchen with his walker, hoping to help with the recycling because I was there and would help him, and it was an activity he enjoyed, feeling engaged. But this time it was 10:30 pm and I just couldn’t give him the hour I knew it would take. He didn’t say what he was there for, but I knew, and I turned away from him in the moment. And shortly after that my husband became completely overwhelmed, and his dad went to a nursing home where he refused more and more to eat, or take his meds, and of course he declined. It’s a tough thing to balance your love and respect for someone, and the shifting priorities that are just a part of life.

I had another point to share, but I’ve gotta go do something else now. ❤️
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
ShirleyDot Nov 16, 2025
It's not a game, it's a type of manipulation. She wants her son to stay as long as possible and visit as much as possible. So she doesn't eat if he isn't there and eats very slowly when he is there.
(2)
Report
I replied before suggesting a video link between Mom and family. There's lots of links that could be useful where you can be together, while you're apart. Jubilee TV is $40 monthly and it seems very easy to use. It doesn't seem limited so you can spend as much time as it takes for Moms meals. People also use it for surveillance to keep an eye on their loved ones. You can be in two places at once, isn't that what you're striving for? Tell Mom you're a TV star if that's what it takes, you're on location and this is how you can make time for her.
Another possibility is to replace yourself with an object,as in a doll, stuffed animal or an AI pet( I saw a real cutie, so life like) that could be a companion for her. Eat together and excuse yourself from the room, leaving them alone. Eventually, it will become a habit for her to eat with your replacement? Those little AI animals are so realistic and some actually cuddle. Does Mom understand the situation you're in? How have you discussed it with her? Maybe if she understands that she could lose you and your wife and her grandchildren she might make an effort? She's too young to be this difficult, she has lots of years left. Your wife knows that and it's a long term burden to place on your family. I'm surprised that you are tolerating this so far, what a tug of war!!
So, this being all on your shoulders, it's time to set the boundaries before you're torn apart. Tell the facility about your situation and you need time to work in out. They should understand!! Tell Mom and family WHAT YOU WANT TO DO as you're the middle man and you can only be stretched so far. This is what you can do for both sides and keep yourself well! You're not going to be there for either side if this continues, you'll end up ill and needing care yourself. You must be close to a nervous breakdown, panicked and torn with so much responsibility. Take charge and take care! If this were me? I'd scream bloody murder in my car and beat on the steering wheel and then decide what's best for ME to get through this. Caregiving sucks, it's a no win, just lots of sacrifices with no appreciation. Good luck friend
"I'm the best Me,
I can be"
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
bb1807868 Nov 17, 2025
I tried FaceTime a couple of times she goes into ADD mode and gets utterly distracted. Defeated the purpose.

As for letting it out, will say this coupled with a 24 hour gym have been great for my overall physical health. Mental health is questionable, but yeah in the best shape I have been in since my swimming days.

In her world sharing dinner as a family is the norm, that is how we did it at home. No TV just the mom, dad, and myself together at the table. It was the time we spent with one another. Finding out how our days went, my mom would always want me to share one new thing I learned. Even with her dementia she still acts like I in school and asks what new thing did I learn.

Another poster hit the nail on the head, dinner is family time. I wish Zoom or FaceTime worked but yeah. Trust me I even thought of making a 3D model and creating a pseudo virtual assistant. Build the data set off everything I know so she can interact with a virtual model of myself, and even other family members that have ghosted her over the years.

Her world has become much smaller, but I have to protect myself. Maybe a part of her does want to do "The Long Walk" so to speak but I legally cannot let her starve herself without trying to get her to eat. I also just don't buy that theory as others have pointed out because she does eat.

I do agree with that one poster who mentioned family time may he her only reason left to live. Way I see it is if that is the case why take that away from her before dementia robs her of it anyways?

Dementia takes and takes. All it knows is destruction, it does not need my help in destroying what little happiness she has left.

Thank you for the words though, and thanks for reading my little rant.
(1)
Report
I think you just do your best to find her a place that will take her, and that you don't mention the need for one-on-one feeding. Continue to see her for lunch, and that's it. Let the chips fall where they may. I think it is highly unlikely that the state is going to bring some type of charge against you for neglecting your responsibilities as guardian. She has early onset Alzheimers and they do eventually stop eating. I think that there would only be an investigation if someone files a complaint. Who would do that? Stop worrying about this, deal with the problem of getting her in a new home, and let it be. Don't lose your family over this.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Basictakes99 Nov 16, 2025
Guardianship requires annual reporting where they are required by law to document everything for the courts. OP would be legally obligated to disclose everything that has happened and yes he could get in trouble for negligence. Not following the court order and if it leads to extreme weightloss that could be seen as a form of negligence and the courts would come after him for that.

The facility is also going to be in full CYA mode they are 100% also documenting everything. When it comes to dealing with Guardianship and courts being proactive is generally for the best.

OP don't gamble with the courts you are not rich, you are a normal person.
(1)
Report
See 11 more replies
It seems to me that you don't have much choice than to look for another place for your mom. Your wife has made a stand. A smaller place with more individual attention to each resident may work better for your mom. I'm sorry that you are having this to deal with. She has dementia and it will only get worse. As it is early onset she may decline more quickly.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Have you looked into a group home like setting? These places have smaller case loads and have one on one care that you may be looking for. Sometimes aides can be brought in for sitting.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
bb1807868 Nov 17, 2025
Not yet, I have to first buy time since her current facility wants to remove her and with guardianship it is not that simple to move someone. I need to find one, and the facility in question has to agree to the courts plan of care so to speak so a lot hurdles. ATM I am doing all I can just to keep my mom where she is cause if she gets kicked out getting her replaced from the community will be a huge PITA and take a lot of time.

Once she was placed I mistakenly stopped looking cause she was placed in memory care and I thought that was it. Never thought this would happen after I stopped eating dinner with her.

The plan is to find alternative placement but first I want to see if I can come to an agreement with her current facility to keep her if I make sure she has someone to eat with her three times a day.

Getting ready to have breakfast with her, and going to try a bunch of different things to front load her calories. Her doctors are okay with the idea and her numbers are solid so they said I could go heavy on suger if need be since it might be a taste bud thing.
(4)
Report
I have already posted but felt the need to answer again. Your mom needs a meal buddy... However you can make that happen. Many seniors with dementia don't recognize hunger or thirst. People with dementia usually eat so much better if they have someone with them eating with them. Someone that they take to ...it does not have to be a family member. You may be able to work out something with a facility to where they send someone to sit and interact with your mom during meal time. You may have to hire someone or find a volunteer. Whether or not she's manipulative is beside the point. Most people with dementia are manipulative. This struck a chord for me because I was formally a CNA who did work privately in nursing homes etc to make sure that my patients did eat etc. Nursing homes rarely have the time to make sure that every single resident is eating... Those CNAs and nurses are spread very thin. I had to quit at one of the nursing homes I was working in privately. Sadly the family never replaced me and the patient failed to thrive. It truly broke my heart. I also had a mom with vascular dementia, so I know what it's like to be a child of someone with dementia and to care for people with dementia. You are in a very sad situation that's complicated. But try as best as you can to simplify it and realize that your mom needs help... Again it doesn't have to be you who is the meal buddy although I'm sure you're still going to visit your mom. She just needs a buddy.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
bb1807868 Nov 17, 2025
That is also an end goal but unfortunately I don't have the income or time really to hire someone at thia point. So I will be doing it myself until I can find an alternative.

I do know what she needs, just unfortunately I am limited by the fact facility does not have the staffing and I don't have the extra income to hire someone. Until, I find a charity service or make more money it is on me.

That is what makes this situation so frustrating since the fix is easy yet hard.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
I hope you can come back here in a few months and provide an update.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Yes, please let us know how you and your family are doing.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
bb1807868 Nov 18, 2025
First day was not so bad, my mom ate each meal without much hassle and dinner was small buy quick since majority of her calories were front loaded. Dinner she was done in record time, and she apparently was active and engaged with her community.

Got home around 7:30 my time, but got out of work at 5:30ish. Just one day but was a good one. Still got to hang with the family thumbs up all around from me.
(0)
Report
From what I am reading, your mother holds the top place in your life, and the needs of your immediate family are lower down in your priorities. I understand that in emergencies this may have to be the case, but once the crisis has passed. in a healthy family, wife child/children come first.

I agree with the poster below who states that you going there 3 times a day is not necessary to see that your mother eats enough. Her calorie needs will not be great, and should be able to be met. as someone suggested by a couple of smoothie type meals a day. I suspect you going there 3 times a day is more about meeting your needs than hers.

Do you have a job? How can you maintain work while devoting this much time to your mother? It seems to me not doable.

Personally I would be scouring the countryside to find a facility who would give your mother attention at meals. When my mother was in an NH. the aides helped her and others to eat.

Your stated solution is to be with your mother for three meals a day. Looking for another facility comes after that. So you may be bound to this regime for some time. I have to wonder at your motivation and your ties to your mother. All the legal speak seems to me to be justifying your position. And all this at the cost of your immediate family - wife and child/children. I find it quite sad.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Caregiveronce Nov 17, 2025
Yes, I would rather be a bad daughter than a bad wife and mother. When you get married you "leave and cleave." Like you said, there is absolutely nothing wrong helping in the short term, but saying "Oh well, I guess I will end up divorced," is downright sad.
(1)
Report
See 5 more replies
M is being provided with food by the facility, which OP has arranged. That is not ‘neglect’. Anyone who thinks that not sitting with her while she eats food that is in front of her, is on a par with abuse, fraud and theft, is underestimating the brain power of the court system.

BB is putting an enormous effort into supporting what he has decided to do. If he manages to post this on his phone on the one-hour trip home, he would definitely be in legal trouble where I am. If he is doing it at work, he needs to concentrate on getting a raise. He has been trained into this by a very clever 67 year old. W is better off out of it.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
bb1807868 Nov 17, 2025
Yeah making more money is just that simple. I live in a HCOL state yet make enough to support my family on a single income. By most metrics I am doing pretty well.

If you must know, I do park and ride. So I am not driving the entire way to work. Secondly sometimes things are slow and I check my phone throughout the day.

Maybe if we had dual income household I could use money instead of time but I cannot force my wife to work. That is her call and her choice. All I can do is provide the best possible care I can for those in my life.

Also remember the neglect is based off the end result. If she is not eating and dies from starvation you really think courts will be like yeah she was old it happens? I think you are underestimating that some courts actually care about the wellbeing of their wards.

The end result is what will determine the neglect not just the action in itself.

Leaving your 6 year old alone is not inherently illegal. If nothing bad happens no one is none the wiser. Is it smart? Probably not but sometimes it has to be done.

Though if your six year old burns down the apartment due to not being under supervision you think courts give a shit about the raw intent in the grand scheme of the end result?
(0)
Report
Keep doing what you are doing... brainstorming with the input from this forum. Let your wife know you are on it and doing your best to get this under control so to speak. Our best to you
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
MargaretMcKen Nov 17, 2025
He probably can’t keep doing it. The facility wants M out because she does not actually need SNF care. M’s stellar career does not seem to have provided her with funds. BB cannot afford AL. BB takes her home, W leaves, M improves and enjoys the whole thing. BB wakes up???
(1)
Report
See 3 more replies
I'm pretty sure no one (except perhaps some hard-hearted administrator at the SNF) intended for you and your family to be in this situation. Your wife might (or might not) be willing to have a truce if you, in good faith, promise to reevaluate the situation in a few months. Maybe things will be better then; maybe they won't. But at least you'll have those few months to try your current plan. I wish you well. I want your mom to be safe and healthy, your marriage to survive, and you to survive this very difficult time in your life.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Can you hire additional help at private pay to come help her with meals? Private care staffing agencies is who you would call. You would have to pay out of pocket. Since your mother is on Medicaid and likely has no money. It might be enough to keep her at the facility in familiar surroundings. I respect your wife and do not bring your mother to your house. Are there different hospice agencies to choose from?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
bb1807868 Nov 17, 2025
My income is kind of capped out now. I did see if my wife would be willing to work part time while the kids are in school, then I could replace myself with money.

Was looking at sites like care.com to see what the going rate is. Not keen on taking extra work. My current job ia stressful enough as is. We will see though.

I am maxing out my contributions to our accounts including our children don't want to skimp on that but worse case I am thinking of it. I can still do lunch cause she is close by to my job. Would be around 80 a day, since many have four hour min.

If we cut we can cover the$ 1600 extra a month. Wife would not be pleased. It adds up and that is not counting weekends. We do weekends that will be $2240.

I will have to figure it out and check more in depth.
(2)
Report
Will your wife agree to go have one meal a day with her at the facility if that keeps her at the facility? It may be a temporary fix but may buy time.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
MargaretMcKen Nov 18, 2025
That's an hour's drive in each direction for W, and they don't seem to like each other much. However if M doesn't eat for W, it might prove something.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
This situation continues to make me sad as your mom is a year younger than me and I was a former CNA that worked with dementia patients for 12 years and an HR manager in a at-home care service for a year. One thing that this forum has done is make my husband and I realize that we need to get long-term healthcare insurance now. It is also made it very clear to me how difficult being a caregiver for a family member can be on someone as young as you. I have to say is that early onset dementia or dementia in general affects a whole family. People with dementia act differently because they see the world differently. Are they a bit manipulative. Yes. I think you do have to make sure that your mom is taken care of and it would be nice to have the support of your family. And these days it is very difficult for a family to thrive without two incomes. I have a son who has small children and his wife had to go back to work Part-Time because they just need the money. My husband and I are up there 3 days a week to watch the kids. I do not charge him for this service... He is my family and they are my grandchildren. You have in a sense lost your parents very young. You have a great deal of responsibility... To your mom and to your family. It would be very sad to have your family break up over the fact that you were worried about your mom's care. Many of the suggestions that were put in place I think were logical and well meaning. Your mom does better eating when she's with someone else and that's the bottom line. The fact that she 's still young to have dementia is beside the point...she has it. So, The answer would be that she needs a meal buddy however you can make that happen. Perhaps even the facility could spare someone to sit with her at least during one meal. You might have to pay a little bit extra... $20 a day or so. Her failure to thrive is because she's not taking in enough calories. Those of us who have worked with dementia patients see it all the time. You seem to have a good handle on many things. Just keep figuring out how you can make sure that your mom is eating without you actually having to be there all the time. I honestly hope we are all helping you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
bb1807868 Nov 18, 2025
Yeah yesterday looked at sites like care.com messaged some people they all had four hour min at 20 per hour some were more. I will look into more, when things settle one of the staff here recommended me to check nursing schools since she claims this type of service could court towards their required hours.

That will be my next attempt. I can swing 20 a day, but 80 a day adds up pretty quickly. I did try to get her LTC insurance but she did not pass underwriting.

Unfortunately, situations like mine are becoming more and more common. Maybe I am naive but I don't agree that this has to be an either or situation between good husband / father and son. Like some have mentioned here. I think one can be all three.

Even her doctors find my mother's situation sad. Health wise she took very good care of herself. She has no other issues, we don't even know why this happened. Was fine the day before next morning she was extremely confused and downhill from that point.

Her MRI's don't show signs of stroke or infracts chronic or otherwise. It is weird. We tried things like the infusion and stuff to slow progression but yeah no idea if it did anything or not.

I legit lost my mom that day. She was fine the night before, last time I saw her normal she was having a glass of wine watching baseball.

Something switched. It is painful, and sad. If it was not for support groups I would not even have somewhere to vent. You know the worse part about all of this, I never got any of her recipes. I miss the little things so much. Her saying see you tomorrow god willing. Her putting up her hands in a playful motion like she was going to fight you when you say something silly with that big smile of hers. I miss my kids will never get to try her cookies or have her take them to a baseball game. I hate that the person who showed me what strength truly is now is at the mercy of others.

This was a women who taught herself many languages, worked her way through school, who's parents left her with her grandparents. Never once heard her complain about the hand life dealt her. She always took everything in stride. As she use to say, god does not give you more than you can handle.

I will get through this, I am her son after all. I have the strength of both my parents on my side.

It is sad you can take care of yourself and still get screwed over in the end life is really funny. Worse part people will still judge and act like your life suddenly has less value or even blame them for their lack of planning. Like that does anything. My wife does that and likes to say don't live in the past. Yet she focuses on my mother's lack of planning all the time. It is weird. I get this is a less than ideal situation. No one our age should be in this situation. We are barely in our 30's. It is not fair but it is what is no. All we can do is adapt and move forward.
(1)
Report
I understand. If you can get a nursing student or someone with a good heart who wouldn't mind sitting with your mom for an hour each day. I know plenty of CNAs who would do this on the side. This would help you be a little bit more balanced and caring for your mom and your family. It's very difficult to do and I understand as my mom had dementia also.
Keep putting out your feelers to see where you can get help.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I have only read a portion of the responses here, and maybe someone has said this already… I study and teach nutrition at a very basic level. You have said you are able to go there for lunch because she is near your work. I believe good research shows that only one really good meal is necessary each day, and it’s actually best if that meal is midday. I also had a mother who died with dementia. Her breakfast was an English muffin, and her dinner was an English muffin with cocoa. With a good single meal at lunchtime, calorically she was OK, especially if she drank an Ensure during the day. That was easy because it tasted like chocolate milk, and she liked her “milkshake”. She would drink those if prompted.

I am wondering if your once-a-day meal visit is enough. Perhaps you can hire a person for the midday meal on Saturday and Sunday. That’s only ~$50 a week. Our AL has several “off menu” items you can order any meal, like toast and an egg or other light and simple things. Perhaps there is something like that they can serve her, but if she doesn’t eat it’s no big deal. I do not think three meals a day is necessary, and if she skips breakfast and won’t eat much dinner that’s ok if she had a good lunch. Again, perhaps focus on getting one good meal a day in, not three.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
MG8522 Nov 18, 2025
I know someone with an eating disorder who eats only once a day, but makes it a very large meal, and she has lived this way for many many years at a thin but normal weight with no obvious problems.
(1)
Report
See 2 more replies
Wow this conversation just goes round and round in circles. You’re so committed to this codependency with your mom that you’ve backed the facility into a corner where they can’t deal with your insistence that your mom have one on one entertainment for three hours a day. Them asking her to leave lets you continue with this savior complex where you’re the only one who can keep her alive.

Somehow you’ve also found an attorney who is enabling your martyrdom by agreeing that you will go to prison for murder if you don’t spend all your time hanging out with her for every meal.

You are intent on arguing with every piece of advice you are offered because the only answer you seemingly will accept is that you’re right, you have no choice but to perform this exhausting dance with your mom, and that your wife is being unfair for thinking you should come home and pay attention to your family every once in a while. You’re so insistent that your mom is entitled to “family time” with you at every single meal but you’re not giving that same family meal time to your own family even once a day. This whole discussion is wild to me.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
AlvaDeer Nov 18, 2025
Slart, I so agree. This is SO answered already, yet every day it goes up at least 10 points with more answers. We are now getting answers repeated. It DOES happen here, and it sure is happening now. I thought the same thing today.
(2)
Report
These comments are devolving into being very unhelpful to the OP, imo, and the thread should be closed to further posts. What else can possibly be said here besides sniping and ugly judgements??
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter