Follow
Share

I don’t mean this to sound so heartless, really I don’t I’m just wondering from others experience how long after this happens do the elderly & frail manage to go on once they stop managing to do these tasks? as far as we are aware she has no dementia or Alzheimer’s, she’s just very very frail. The nurses who visit her have no concerned there. She has progressively got worse over the last two years, she’s now very thin, doesn’t leave the house unless she has an appointment (husband drives her). He is her carer, we and she are very lucky that she only lives ten minutes away and husband has a flexible job so he goes to see her to make her breakfast, pops back to make her lunch and then stops by on the way home to make her dinner. She didn’t admit she couldn’t prepare food until I asked her, I noticed also the house was actually not being cleaned (basic stuff like cleaning toilet and kitchen, hoovering!) I started by cleaning her toilet when I visit, then told husband he needs to start doing other bits when he’s there, she hasn’t got the energy to even wash plates after eating (we have to rewash them). Considering getting a cleaner in too to help. husband doesn’t want her in a home as we think this would really upset her (she’s said she doesn’t want to end up in a home) and as it’s all working ok at the moment it’s ok, but I’m aware it’s a strain on my husband, it’s a lot. He phones her regularly during the day, is basically her entertainment, social life, makes sure she eats and cleans the house, manages her appointments, the lot. Bless her, she just sits in her chair all day long. So without sounding heartless, I have no experience myself of this (and hopefully won’t!!) but when it gets to this stage how long realistically can the older person go on for? Though I realise then the loss of his mother when she eventually does pass would be really hard on my husband, he’s an only child, I suspect there would be some relief in some form too as he’s constantly worrying about her.

Nobody wants to end up in a home but many people have to end up in a home. It’s just how it is sometimes.
Helpful Answer (15)
Reply to southernwave
Report

Your MIL can go on like this another decade with all the help shes getting and no disease at play. The better question to ask is how long your husband can go on like this? Placing his mom in Assisting Living would ensure she was taken care of, fed, bathed and entertained, and that he'd be free of providing that service FOR her.

Best of luck to you.
Helpful Answer (14)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report
Slartibartfast Jan 12, 2026
And placement would significantly slow down her decline, because she will get proper nutrition, mental stimulation, and get out of her chair and bed.
(14)
Report
As long as you and husband continue to do everything for her, expect her to expect it. She will decline at home but might perk up if she had a living arrangement with other people her age, activities, and outings. By refusing professional care in a place where she could thrive, she's put herself on a path that only has one end: she dies at home. Or she falls at home and then dies at home. Or something bad happens, like a stroke, and she goes to the hospital and rehab and they send her to die at home. Husband and you get to supervise and coordinate all of this. She's groomed him well.

My mother lived to 95, my father to 92, Rude Aunt to 102, and Nasty Grandpa to 95. What fun!
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
Lylii1 Jan 20, 2026
You are so right! The more you do, the more is expected of you. It simply is not realistic! I love your last sentence - made me laugh!
(0)
Report
You’ve received good feedback. Just be very sure hubby never makes the misguided promise that mom will never go into a facility, or will live in her home until end of life. There are too many possibilities to make this promise. Of course it’s not what anyone ever wants, but it’s sometimes necessary and you never want the curse of a mistaken promise hanging over you. Your MIL is daily upping her chances as we all have “use it or lose it” bodies.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

Oh, I had to giggle. I am 83. I ask myself the same question. "How long CAN I go ON".

I think without there being some dementia happening here, the question is -- and this is basically for a good gerontologist WHY is she so fragile? Because the less she does, the more she will deteriorate. Our muscles, tendons, bones need now to keep WORKING or they will melt to nothing. I still walk two miles a day about 5 days out of 7. I do my garden, though having recently battled my Brugmansia back to a good trim over 4 days I am threatening a gardener for fall winter trim should I have to go another year. I still cook and clean, though things lost under the bed are a muttered "DANG", as the knees doth protest. But in short, at 83 and 85 respectively, my partner and I are still functioning for ourselves.
If MIL isn't, then there's a reason. The question is "What is the reason". There may be chronic illnesses? There may be arthritis? Just what is stopping her and can anything be done to maintain independence?

All that said, you now need to be ready to have ongoing discussions. You and doing more and they are doing less and it is why I tell EVERYONE that the best place for our kids is a minimum 1,000 miles away from us. You easily get drawn in to doing more and more and as you do that you enable their denial that they may need to consider other options than leaving their home feet-first.

Now to THE question. How long can she go on? Who knows. My daughter MIL is in her early pushing toward mid-90s. Still active though in Independent Living now. People at times now live to 100. It is anyone's guess. I am on my second bout in my lifetime with breast cancer. But of course, here I still am.

I don't feel your question is at all cruel. In fact that mil of my daughter has herself discussed with family the options for something such as "Dignitas or Pegasos". She is tired. She is almost blind from macular degeneration. She is "over it". In all truth, I myself am more than ready for my final curtain call. They just don't issue us the magic pill to take when we are ready, and there's no good predictor of who, what, where, when and in what manner.

Wishing you the best, but know it is time to discuss with the hubby the future, plans, and most of all LIMITATIONS. If he WILL discuss it, that is.
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report
Lorieaga Jan 12, 2026
Haha, your answer made me smile! My aunty is in her 90’s and still driving around! But as for MIL, it just feels like a vicious circle, the less she does the less she can do. We’ve tried to encourage her to just walk outside a few steps and back, just for the fresh air and try to improve her situation but she won’t. She sits in her chair with the heating on full (I sympathise with this as I have circulatory issues myself!) and will only move briefly to get some water to drink, to use the bathroom and go to bed. Obviously this just makes her worse as she gets breathless which isn’t surprising because the less you do, the less lung capacity you have, less muscle, weaker bones and on it goes. She’s had many tests at the hospital and doctors but there’s nothing diagnosable, just frail and weak. And in the last couple of months, the realization she hadn’t got the strength to prepare meals or clean. I suppose I was asking the question because she isn’t active, and seems to have no interest in helping herself and that’s the main issue really that she’s getting less and less active. Perhaps she feels she’s “over it” also but doesn’t want to say as much? Thank you for your response, it was actually a really nice read.
(3)
Report
See 3 more replies
Definitely would get a housekeeper in to clean the whole house really well once a month. Perhaps consider hiring a CNA or caregiver to come a few days a week to make sure she showers and gets exercise. They can also do lighthouse keeping,laundry, and prepare some meals ahead of time including sandwiches and snacks. If you and your husband live close could you perhaps make a little extra for when you make for yourselves and bring it by a few times a week, or eat with her? To put weight on, I would sometimes combine Carnation instant breakfast with frozen yogurt. Egg salad tuna and chicken salad sandwiches are also really good for seniors. Your mother may be getting to the point where she just wants to graze... So make sure either you or her caregiver leave things in the fridge that she can pick on.
She needs a little extra help and care.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Hrmgrandcna
Report

My mom is going to be 99 in March. She does not have dementia. She was scheduled to have a knee replacement, and then Covid hit so elective surgeries were put on the back burner. When Covid was over, her doc refused to do the surgery because of her age and how the anesthesia would affect her brain. So she shuffled around her apartment where she lived alone using furniture as her cane. She stopped cooking and just used her microwave. She couldn’t do major cleaning - her bathroom suffered. She got a UTI and ended up fainting and was on the floor for 36 hours. She ended up in a nursing home for good because she couldn’t walk. I wish she had agreed to go to a nursing facility sooner. She might have been offered physical therapy. So she is now in a wheelchair all day. My expectation is that she will make it to 100, but I wish she had professional help sooner.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Kartyjb
Report

Could someone talk to your MIL's doctor about a low dose of antidepressants, to see if that might help with motivating her to do more than sit in the chair? It may turn out to be physical, that she just doesn't have strength, but it may be, as you said below, a vicious circle because she isn't motivated and that causes further decline.

Her husband should hire a cleaner to come in so that your husband doesn't have to do so much work. Your husband can also sign them up for Meals on Wheels which should take care of one or two meals a day. They can get frozen microwave meals like Healthy Choice. Have the groceries delivered. Get a good supply of paper plates and plastic cups and utensils to cut down on the need for dishwashing.

See if some of her doctors can do video visits, and send a nurse or tech to their home for things like drawing blood and blood pressure checks.

No one wants to go to a care home, but sometimes it's necessary. Maybe you could help by calling around to a few and getting their brochures so that if it reaches that point, some preliminary work will already be done.

Sometimes it does take an in-law, like yourself, to see the practical realities when the family is too close to the situation to be realistic. Your husband needs to protect himself from burning out and becoming resentful, and making you resentful also.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to MG8522
Report

Your mother-in-law might live for many more years. Or she might not. My mom is almost 97 1/2 years old, doesn't move much, lives in an assisted-living memory care facility, and has days when it seems as though she's about to die. And yet she's still alive.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Rosered6
Report

I'm concerned not only for your husband, but MIL's husband, who is caring for her. How much longer can HE go on?
People can live a surprisingly long time even when they can no longer manage their ADL's - Activities of Daily Living. If she is less active and sitting all day, she will also become weaker and will become a fall risk. Her son and her husband can not continue like this without help.

You could hire someone through a home care agency to come to the home regularly to do light housekeeping, prepare a meal, and provide companion or assistance with personal cares if needed. Your In-Laws pay for this, not you.
Then, your husband can stop by simply to visit and spend quality time with her.
That would be a much better use of his time and energy, and she will enjoy having his undivided attention.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report
iameli Jan 20, 2026
After reading the original post again carefully, I’m not sure there is a husband of the MIL in the picture. I think it’s OP’s husband doing everything.
My husband was in the same position, his brother died pretty young and his mother called him for everything. Except that she had cancer. Once she reached the point where she wasn’t taking care of herself, she only lived about another six weeks. But she was very sick already. I agree that with no underlying illness a person could go on for quite a while, with someone coming in every day to feed and take care of them.
(2)
Report
See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter