Follow
Share

Hubs moved his mom a year ago against my wishes. He and his sister work, I take care of kids,animals, and house ( sister has no kids). I told them i could help but was not comfortable giving the care she needed and she needed to stay in rehab or nursing home. I specifically outlined what would happen after her 21day stay and that everyday after she was paying over 200 a day to be there so USE the REHAB while ur there. She never tried to get up to use the restroom in rehab, and when the bill came do. She freaked! I was the idea to take care of her since I don't work. I protested and protested but a year later her she is. I told my hubs at Thanksgiving ( when sister will be here) I'm simply going to ask what their plan is? I can not continue to take care of all of my responsibilities plus theirs! I'm thinking of saying something like, I would like to see her in her own place by the beginning of summer. Is that to harsh? It will have been 18months of living here at that point.

Find Care & Housing
YOU don't get your MIL to move out. This is a discussion your husband has with his mother.
You have a discussion with your husband as to what you want to change.
Would having a caregiver..that MIL pays for improve the situation?
Would having your husband be more hands on with her care help the situation? You want her in her own place by summer. Can she manage on her own? Would Assisted Living be better for her?

I also should ask you if MIL paid you for your caregiving duties would that help? (do a quick search for the cost of caregivers in your area. It could be anything from $25.00 to $50.00 per hour more for live in or 24 hour care. It all depends on the care she needs and if medication is involved the cost would be much higher.
MIL should also be paying her FAIR share of ALL household expenses. Is she?
By all expenses I mean if there are 5 people living in the house she should be paying 1/5 of mortgage, gas bill, electric, cable, food and all the rest.

Your feelings and request is valid, this is your home as well.
The big question is if push comes to shove is this a choice of you or your MIL that your husband has to make?
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report
Simplytired Nov 21, 2025
Thanks for answering. I 100% COMPLETELY AGREE this is my husband's responsibility but it's also my home too. If he will not bring it up then I will have to. We have multiple conversations and go round and round. I simply say let's make a plan. And he doesn't know what to do from there. I got to the point that the actual stress between my husband and I was causing issues with my health. So I told him we need to have a family discussion. At Thanksgiving when his sister is here, let's just approach it as it's been this long, whats the next step in the plan? We would like to see something happening in the next few months to make that next step. Soo... to answer some of your questions. She is very generous with her money. Her money buys the groceries for the house (4ish people) 1 kid buys their own. And she pays me about $50 a week. I have no idea what she gives my husband. And honestly it's not that she is like a huge handful it's just the stress of having another responsibility. At the beginning she was 100% a huge handful but the past 3 months she is capable of almost everything, she just don't want to do it. That in its self I have have no sympathy for. Our children are all almost adults but this youngest one but that does not mean I am not busy and I am looking forward to a life after kids. I feel like that is never coming when I now have to make sure another person is fed, clean, clothed, doctors and everything else that goes with it. I do feel sympathetic for my husband trying to take care of his mom but HE is NOT the one doing all these things. I was a caregiver for my grandmother with dementia. It took alot out of me and although I was devastated. I was relieved when I no longer had to be a caregiver. It was exactly 1 year to the month that I got that relief.She lived in a facility within walking distance from my house so even though she was family, I could get a somewhat of a sense of leaving work at work and coming home. I also don't have that feeling now with my MIL living here. So to answere all of the questions about bringing help in. No. I just want to feel like a normal 38yr old again getting to enjoy life without all the extra for at least a little while.
(6)
Report
See 1 more reply
Simply, this isn't a MIL problem.
This is a marital issue and marital problem.
I would sit down and tell husband that you cannot now go on and that you don't intend to, and that you don't intend to argue about it. I would tell him that he needs to address placement now for his Mom. I would give him a time limit, and I would tell him that after that time limit is up you will be going to a divorce attorney.

I caution you that, before making this move, you make certain to take out money into an account of your own, as you husband may make very quick and certain moves to secrete his money away to places where you cannot access it, thus attempting to prevent any escape of his slave-labor.
Helpful Answer (18)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

I’m sorry you’ve been taken advantage of in your own home. Your husband should respect your boundaries and his marriage more than he seems to be doing. Please make it clear that you will not continue as is, I’d highly recommend NOT saying you’ll do this until summer. That only gives them an excuse not to make changes. It doesn’t take that long to find a new living arrangement. Be firm. You may have to go visit family or a friend for a while and leave the responsibility entirely to your husband if he refuses to understand. I wish you courage and peace
Helpful Answer (13)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

I think you need to give your husband an ultimatum that she must live elsewhere because you no longer want to be her caregiver. Don’t be so nice about giving a six month deadline. You are being exploited.

Are you cooking Thanksgiving dinner on top of it all?
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to Hothouseflower
Report

I think that you should take your kids and move out for 2-4 weeks leaving your husband to have take care of his mom full-time. He will have to take a leave from work but who cares...it's his mom not yours.
I can only guess that after those weeks of him having to deal with his mom 24/7 that he will be more than happy to get her placed in the appropriate facility.
And if not you may have to leave with the kids permanently, as any man that would put his mom before his wife and kids is no man at all and should be kicked to the curb.
Like Alva said below, this is really a marriage issue and not a MIL issue.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to funkygrandma59
Report

Are you kidding? The deadline should be six days, not months.

On whichever day next week your children finish school (Tuesday or Wednesday), take them and your pets directly to somewhere else. Family, or an inexpensive airbnb, even if it's just in town. Don't tell him WHERE you're going, Don't answer any phone calls from him. Tell him that he and his sister are fully responsible for their mother Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. Tell him by the time you get home on Sunday evening, they will need to have a plan because you will not be caring for their mother during the upcoming week, or any other week either. They need to take FMLA from their jobs until their mother is removed from your home, permanently. (If you homeschool your children, leave as soon as your husband comes home from work tomorrow.)

And don't ever describe yourself as "I don't work." Taking care of children IS work. Stop devaluing yourself. Seriously, how dare he?
Helpful Answer (18)
Reply to MG8522
Report

I would talk with your husband and if needed get marital counseling. Hopefully you two can visit facilities together to find a new home for MIL.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to JustAnon
Report

You don't ask, you tell. MIL needs placement after New Years. If she can afford it, a nice assisted living. If not a board and care or Longterm care with Medicaid paying. She is not your responsibility, she is theirs.
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

I don’t think MIL “is very generous with her money”. Groceries (or probably some of them)? About $50 a week to you? And you have no idea what or if she pays to your husband? Check out the cost of care, and rethink ‘generous”. MIL is getting the equivalent of Assisted Living.

MIL “is capable of almost everything, she just don't want to do it”. You stop doing it for her. If you want the holiday season to be peaceful, make the change on first January. Just tell her, your husband and sister of the new rules, and start them immediately. Actions speak louder than words.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
MargaretMcKen Nov 22, 2025
I really doubt if you have any idea of what MIL should be paying to live in your house with you doing nearly all her care. You say “she was paying over 200 a day to be in Rehab and when the bill came she FREAKED”. It would be a very very good idea for you to visit an Assisted Living facility, find out what services are provided and how yours compare, and get an idea of charges (which aren’t going to be much less than rehab). Tell her – and your H and SIL – and ask why your place shouldn’t charge at the same rate.
(7)
Report
See 1 more reply
Simplytired,
I think you are confusing "responsibility" with having a voice in how you live your life. What I mean is, you do not need to justify how busy you already are. If you are uncomfortable with your MIL living in your house, and you have to spend the most time with her, since you are home, while hubby leaves to go to work, you have every right to ask for your home back, to have peaceful enjoyment of your home life, which you have spent years building.
Your husband is being too passive. He is not making a plan. You must either make the plan, or INSIST that he and/or your Sister-In-Law make a plan that does not include you as their mother's caregiver, or babysitter.
No, that is not too harsh! It is your home. You can reclaim it, whether you have any kids or animals to take care of or not!
Actually, it seems MIL is capable of living independently. No one really needs to make a plan for her, your husband just needs to step up and tell her that living with you indefinitely is not an arrangement that is working out and she will need to find another place to live. And give a deadline! Otherwise, no action will be taken.
Helpful Answer (16)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report
Simplytired Nov 22, 2025
Thank you for answering! And yes you are right! I guess I am just looking for the support to know that just because I want my life back and like u said what we worked hard for, that does not make my a selfish hag! I don't ever look for sympathy and have lived a wonderful life, but at the same time haven given alot and just need a time in life to relax a little. When I told my hubs about this conversation that is to come. I told him I will be generous and understanding but I have to draw a line somewhere and he will also have to choose. If he chooses that he wants her to stay then we will need to see an attorney to agree how to move forward with our assets.
(13)
Report
See 1 more reply
Give 30 days notice. Tell husband and SIL you can no longer take care of MIL.
Don't ask. Tell. January 1 MIL needs to be living elsewhere.

If you have to move out with the kids and animals for 4 weeks and let husband and SIL deal with MIL>
Helpful Answer (14)
Reply to brandee
Report

I agree with the Jan 1 deadline. Give them notice.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to PeggySue2020
Report

Tell them you're looking for a 'mutual' agreement, not a democratic one! Surely you can all three find a solution suitable to each of you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to MonteC
Report

That is awful. I would talk to your husband and tell him that it can not continue. Rehab is where most of the work should be done. If she was not willing to try, then it sounds like she has given up and doesn't want to get better. She and your husband need to know that things will not improve and you are not able to provide the amount and type of care that will be required. At the very least, let him know that he will need to be responsible for her care when he is home including toileting. It doesn't sound like a good situation seeing as your concerns and wishes were disregarded initially. I wish you the best.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to spectrum19007
Report

Give them a solid - here is a place Mom can go OR a caregiver to come in. Yes, more work for you, but it's one time - SHOW sister what it takes. "A Place for Mom" and ask around
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to RainbowHeart
Report
JeanLouise Nov 27, 2025
You lost me at help coming in. She deserves a peaceful heart in her home.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
Just because you don't hold a job outside of the home, doesn't mean you don't "work." I would tell my husband to give her a notice to vacate. He can do it whatever way he wishes. If he refuses, then you give her notice. It's really his responsibility. It's his mother and his sister's mother.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Nan333
Report

Why wait till summer? Give them 30 days. New Year, new life for you. You're being used and manipulated. The family will continue to drag their feet as long as you provide their "solution". Wishing you the very best of luck.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to JeanLouise
Report

Not working outside the home does not give anyone in the world the right to decide how your time is spent or what you will do for others.

No doubt if you talk to your MIL, SIL, and husband at the same time there will very likely be a lot of gaslighting going on because chances are everyone wants the status quo to remain as it is, with you taking care of your MIL 24/7.

Speak to your husband privately and speak to him plainly. Tell him that you cannot ans will not go on with his mother living with you then give him a date that she has to be moved out by, otherwise you will leave him. It is up to him and his sister to make arrangements for their mother. Since he supports you financially because you don't earn, you really can't complain about being responsible for the care of your own kids and the domestic chores. If you're a stay-at-home-whatever this is your responsibility. Dealing with your invalid MIL 24/ is not.

There's another even easier way to slove your problems at home.

Get a job.

If you're at work all day earning, there won't be anyone at home to take care of your MIL. Also, by you working, your husband, SIL, and you can hire people to take care of the animals, clean the house, and provide childcare and share the costs.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report
Cattypatti Nov 27, 2025
She said she could barely keep up with the responsibilities she had at home already, so your solution is for her to go out and get a, what, fifth job? The rare job that "pays" because she's voluntold what to do by everyone else? Really?

Why is it that people that punch in with a time clock (ie, paycheck, you're PAID for your time) think that they own all time everywhere and anybody who does not punch in with a time clock, who has a self-directed day regardless of how it's spent, OWES everyone their time?

Newsflash: They don't.
(0)
Report
See 2 more replies
I would make enquiries on where she could go
Care home -whatever
The cost is non of your business
you can’t sacrifice your sanity and health to save her money
find out all the details then sit down with hubby
remembering this is his mother so an emotional subject so try and be sympathetic but firm
hubby we need a serious talk now- it’s time for your mother to move out
this was never a permanent arrangement and it’s now impacting my health and sanity
Ive made enquiries and these are the options
We need to agree a date and make arrangements
good luck
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Jenny10
Report

Not too harsh at all. Hubs and sis are taking advantage of you.

I think it is not a matter of "ask", and more like " tell" hubs and sis that you are no longer going to do this and that they need to make another arrangement by such and such a date. 30 days is not unreasonable. You don't need to justify your decision. It's your life and if this is not working for you, you have the right to put an end to it. I agree the cost is not your problem.

What this means is that you are setting boundaries to protect yourself. If people don't respect your boundaries there will be consequences. What consequences are you comfortable with? That you will get a job at the end of this period. that you wll simply stop caring for mil, that you will leave for a vacation until other arrangements are made? It's up to you. They have no right to decide how you are going to spend your days.

Yes, this is a touchy subject; however hubs and his sis are using you. I think you are going to have to be firm. I wouldn't give them 6 months but 1, 2 or 3 at the most. Do expect pushback from them. People don't like their comfortable apple carts upset. But you are the one who is suffering and it is up to you to make the change.

Wishing you the best. Stay firm in your own interests Let us know how things go. ((((hugs))))
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to golden23
Report

Husband or not, do not let these people manage their life. I know how you are feeling like you are afraid to speak up and being the bearer of peace keeping; so, you won't upset them, or they get mad at you for setting a boundary. It happens all the time.

Let them get angry. Like somebody else's anger is your problem. Their anger is their problem and not being able to be used any longer. Don't let this drag on any longer. Start applying for jobs to get you out of the home even if it's part time for starters.

I did free caregiving for my younger sister for three years straight with no relief. The cost I calculated was $50,000 a year. Go figure.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Scampie1
Report
JeanLouise Nov 28, 2025
She's not keeping peace, she's being beat down by selfish servitude. I hope she stands up for herself as this family has an abusive mindset.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
"And a man leaves his mother and his father and cleaves unto his wife, and they become one flesh." A man looks to his own family before giving consideration to any other including his own mother or father. A wife can leave an abusing husband, but she cannot divorce him. If your husband is acting in a way that does not accord to your wifely wishes when it comes to someone outside of your family, seek comfort away from him but without violating your marriage bed.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to johnawheeler
Report
MargaretMcKen Nov 27, 2025
Sorry John, you’ve got it wrong. A wife can leave an abusing husband, and she certainly CAN divorce him. “Violating beds’ is a very odd concept, especially as the ‘marriage bed’ was most often in a hotel. Just double check with God, and remember that most Biblical scholarship guesses that Paul was probably gay.
(10)
Report
See 2 more replies
You protested this from the beginning! You approach could be "We need to find a place for your mother." If your willingness and feelings are being completely disregarded, maybe you are not in a relationship you should be in. Might is come to the point of you and the kids and the animals moving out?
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to RedVanAnnie
Report

There is a lot of good advice here. It sounds like your MIL may need assisted living. It would be far easier for you to visit her once a week and take her a meal occasionally than to feel the responsibility of her daily care. She sounds capable but feels entitled. As long as you all do it, she will only continue to give up. It’s not fair to you. I made that mistake of helping to take care of MIL and FIL for eight years. Husband helped too, a lady came in 20 hours a week during the day, and we had a housekeeper every two weeks. I worked full time, had three older dogs, and a daughter in college. The in-laws kept waking up during the night sleep walking, falling out of the bed, and needing constant medical care. After eight years of doing this, my nerves hit a brick wall. I had to stop working for two months because of panic attacks all day. We put them in a nursing home, and had to put two of the dogs put down. I promised myself that I would never do this again. I have come close with my own mother, but her illness was short lived before she passed. I also had help with three siblings and she did not live with us. Don’t do it any longer. MIL is still able to adequately take care of her own life with A LITTLE help.

If she has money saved, the assisted living/nursing home will spend it down first, and she could be switched over to Medicaid eventually when the money runs out. All the best.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to DianaGearhart
Report

I would be A LOT more direct.

I would inform husband "I can't do this anymore. You and your sis need to find a place where your mom can get the care she needs and deserves. I will stop doing this care on Jan 1."
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to BarbBrooklyn
Report

One interesting tactic to try would be to say “lets pool all the income coming in and divide it by three, with an equal share to me. I’m doing as much work as you two”. See what reaction you get from Sis!
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report

Is this your house? If it is, then she needs to get out. If they refuse to listen, then I would either volunteer during the day at my kids school, go to the library, go to Starbucks in get a cool, seasonal job. You can be home when your kids are home. They will have to place her or she will fall and 911 will whisk her away. Tell your husband, you are 100% serious and a divorce lawyer is your next step.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Caregiveronce
Report

You need to go on STRIKE ... and mean it.
What you've been saying and what you are actually doing is incongruent.

'Protested and protested' doesn't mean anything if you keep doing it.

In other words, be clear on your boundaries - what you will and will not do and stick to it.
It might help you and the family if you put this in writing.
If you are having difficulty saying 'no,' while frustrated and exhausted, come to terms with your 'inner dilemna' and be very clear on what you want - and WHY you cave in . . . as this is where your 'problem' comes in. You keep doing what you do not want to do. Until you can answer the WHY AM I DOING THIS ??? the situation will remain the same.

It is a red flag to me hearing "Is that to (too) harsh?" as if you are not confident in what you want nor how you feel. If you allow others to decide what you will and will not do, then that is on you. You will continue to feel exhausted and angry at the situation, and it will then back-fire on you/r your health, if it hasn't already.

You need to develop a backbone - (tough love here).
Otherwise, you will continue to do what others expect and/or demand you do as you continue to be frustrated and angry.
Why not move out for a week or two?
Go to an Air b'n'b or take a mini vacation.
Only you can show them you 'mean business' by your actions.

Put your 'decisions' in writing and have a group meeting.
Then you must stick to your decisions to be taken seriously.
Then go see a therapist. You need this support.

Gena
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to TouchMatters
Report

SimplyTired, I just read your response below from a week ago. Your MIL smokes all day in your house, and when you turn on a fan and open a window IN YOUR HOUSE, she turns the fan off and closes it?! And you have children living in this smoke-filled house, as well as yourself?

I hope you have walked out on your husband and his sister, as some of us suggesting, and are enjoying a MIL-free Thanksgiving holiday long weekend. Please let us know where things stand now. As you can see by all the replies, we care about you.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to MG8522
Report

Simply tired, if M starts smoking inside, put a chair outside and force/help her out and onto it, whatever the weather. That is a very clear and totally understandable way of saying “this is my house, my rules”. It may be the quickest way to force a showdown (and a showdown that is quite justifiable to most people).
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
Simplytired Dec 2, 2025
Thank you for answering! Im hopping on to let everyone know how it went. So just to be clear, I told my hubs like 2 months ago (after having dream after dream my hubs and I were splitting up) that Im ready to have this convo. I planned Thanksgiving or Christmas because that's literally the only time SIL comes to visit. I point blank told him he will have to choose. I know that's harsh and I know that puts him in a spot but this is OUR house. If he wants her to stay the we will meet with lawyer and so on. I have a place to go, he is aware! If he wants me to stay then I have no problems helping find a place for her or even going to visit BUT it must be a shared responsibility. Between us 3 and grandkids and her best friend, she should have a visitor almost everyday. Anyway... its been a tough week. My daughters bday was 2 days b4 Thanksgiving and she totaled my car an hr away from home. She is fine thankfully. With all this and preparing and cooking the cleaning for the holiday I was really hoping my hubs would step in and bring it up at Thanksgiving. He did not. So I waited till the kids were visiting in the kids bedroom. My MIL ate then went directly to her room, so before SIL left i asked if she would be here at Christmas. She said she would stop by. I told her we all needed to set down together and discuss her moms next steps. She asked what I meant and my hubs replied " I think she can live on her own or she needs to find a place". SIL agreed and we discussed possibly moving her back home but agreed we would all talk at Christmas. It's not the conversation I hoped for. But I feel so relieved that the door is open and SIL now knows its time to start figuring some stuff out. But all in all it was recieved well!!! Im now just a little nervous how MIL will take it.
(3)
Report
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter