Follow
Share

We can be having a calm conversation and if my opinion is different than hers she gets angry and defensive. I have learned to drop the topic and let her calm down any suggestions?

Find Care & Housing
Yes, do not argue with or try to "correct" a person with dementia.
What do you think you might gain from having a debate with someone whose brain does not work? It's like having a discussion with a toddler.

What she believes is her reality. When you contradict her reality, it is only more confusing to her, and she probably wonders why you are being so difficult.

It is SO hard to watch our loved ones change! I have been living this with my husband for over 10 years now. He does not have a progressive disease, but suffered a stroke at age 53, which caused a sudden traumatic brain injury. He acts like an impulsive child. I miss my once smart, sweet, loving partner. I used to cry a lot and beg the universe to heal him - to bring back the man I knew. But, of course, this is our new reality, and I have come to accept it.
Someone asked here on this forum how to cope. For me, it takes a sense of humor and a sense of adventure to cope. Just take each day as it is, and find a way to laugh at the craziness of it all. And continue loving the partner who no longer knows how to love you back.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report

I have found these guides extremely helpful...

Rules for engaging our loved ones with dementia:

1) Agree, do not argue

2) Divert, do not attempt to reason

3) Distract, do not shame

4) Reassure, do not lecture

5) Reminisce, do not ask “Do you remember…?”

6) Repeat, do not say “I told you”

7) Do what they can do, don’t say “you can’t”

8) Ask, do not demand

9) Encourage, do not condescend

10) Reinforce, never force


The overall goals should be to:

1) keep them as calm and peaceful as possible 
     (because they are less and less able to bring themselves to this state on their own)

2) keep them physically protected in their environment and from predatory people

3) keep them nourished with healthy foods that they will accept without fighting or forcing

4) keep them in as good a health condition as is possible, that their financial resources will allow and within their desires as expressed in a Living Will (aka Advance Healthcare Directive) 

5) keep them pain-free as possible and within their desires as expressed in a Living Will (aka Advance Healthcare Directive)

The caregiving arrangement needs to work for both the receiver and the giver. If it is onerous to the caregiver, then the arrangement is NOT working. Alternative types of care must be considered to avoid caregiver burnout. 
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
DrBenshir May 26, 2026
I think people should print this out and put it where we can see it (but our loved one can't.) Thank you!
(0)
Report
You’ll increasingly learn to enter her world as she’s sadly leaving yours. I’m glad you’ve stopped trying to reason with her. My son lost most reasoning skills, the consequences of a birth defect and the surgeries that followed. We know not to reason with him, but after more than 30 years, still sometimes find ourselves falling into it. Read all you can about dementia and tips to cope with it, stick around this forum as there’s a load of wisdom here, and be sure to take regular breaks from caregiving. Please get your wife accustomed to accepting help that’s not you, it will be good for you both. I wish you both peace
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

I think you have come to the right solution.
One lesson you learn is that you will NEVER win an argument with a person with dementia.
Changing the topic helps.
Switching to something totally different like taking a break and getting a cup of coffee, tea will help as a distraction.
Even just leaving the room for a bit ..."Honey I have to use the bathroom, we can finish talking when I get back" You will be gone long enough to break the conversation.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report

You might want to speak with her doctor about this. My father in law became more and more angry and defensive until he became violent. He was such a calm and gentle man before dementia that it was very shocking to see. Thankfully doctors finally were able to find the right meds for him to keep him calmer. With dementia sometimes a person does not process what is going on correctly and thinks they are being attacked or insulted when that's not happening.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to JustAnon
Report

The Alzheimer's Association has a mantra of don'ts for caregivers: CART. It stands for

Don't Correct
Don't Argue
Don't Reason
Don't Test (eg do you remember, do you jnow, etc)

Very practical, although hard to do all the time.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to pamela78702
Report

I also have a problem giving that up and just dropping the topic. I find that usually there is a time of day that's worse so I try to do a lot of my talking to him when he's not combative but leave some triggers out completely.
You're doing the right thing.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Firefly71
Report

My suggestion is to think about YOURSELF in all this chaos, and get some respite from your wife by hiring in home help regularly or sending her off to a Memory Care Assisted Living facility for a couple of weeks periodically. Visit with your friends and have a few beers so you can carry on intelligent conversations without worrying about angering them. Dementia care is a huge amount of work for one person to manage, so make sure you take time out for yourself.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

i researched it for you: …
you are already doing the right thing by dropping the topic and stepping back. When someone with dementia gets angry during a disagreement, it is usually because the disease impairs their brain's ability to process logic, making corrections or differing opinions feel threatening. 
Alzheimer's Society
 +4
The goal is to focus on how she feels rather than the facts. Try these communication strategies: 
ActivCare® Living

Validate emotions first: Instead of arguing, acknowledge her feelings. Say something empathetic like, "I can see why that is upsetting you". The goal is to make her feel heard, not to agree with her.
Do not use the word "No": Direct disagreement often triggers defensiveness. Try to start with "Yes" and then phrase your thought as a gentle suggestion.
Redirect the conversation: Once she feels validated, pivot the topic away from the argument. Change the subject to a completely different, enjoyable activity or a happy, familiar memory.
Keep language simple: Use short sentences, a soft and calm tone, and warm body language (e.g., gentle eye contact or holding her hand) to offer comfort and reassurance. 
www.carelink.org
 +11
For further guidance, resources and support for navigating communication and behavioral changes are available from the Alzheimer's Society or the National Institute on Aging. 
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Jenny10
Report

Do no try to reason with your wife anymore.

Answer her questions with, "What do you think?" If you hear an undesired subject, agree with her, then change the subject to something else both of you like.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Patathome01
Report

See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter