Follow
Share

My mother is currently living with my sister. She is 76 years old and has been diagnosed with Alzheimer's. My sister has a large breed dog and my mother likes to irritate him (my sister's words). So... They have a lock on the outside of my mother's bedroom door so that she doesn't get attacked. They're to keep my mother safe. Is this legal to do in any state ?

Find Care & Housing
Bottom line: Caregivers need their sleep, period. It simply amazes me how people are easily to criticize and cast judgment on someone trying to regulate an elder that may be a fall risk or in this case mauled by a dog. The sister is generous to take on elder care.

I agree with Burnt on this one. Memory care units are locked to keep residents from eloping.

Dementia can be a very unpredictable disease. Whereas a person may not have wandered before, may get disoriented, wake up in the middle of the night and leave.

It's not a matter of what's right or wrong at this point, but what is safe for the moment for everyone involved until other permanent arrangements can be made.

Also, don't expect caregivers to arrange their entire lives to accommodate an aging elder and their needs. Caregivers need to work. This is not the 50's where women stayed home and took care of homes, meals, laundry and elderly parents.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Scampie1
Report
funkygrandma59 15 hours ago
Scampie, being locked in a bedroom is very different than being locked in a memory care facility as the folks there can at least leave their bedrooms and go to the dining area, activity room or another room to visit if they so choose.
The OP didn't say in their post that their mom was just being locked in overnight, but instead implied that this was for longer periods to keep her away from the dog.
Either way it's very dangerous anyway you slice it, and either the dog has to go or mom needs to be placed in a memory care facility.
And I opt for mom to placed in a facility where she'll be around other folks her own age and be able to socialize if she wants to.
(5)
Report
See 1 more reply
I will assume this is for nightime only. Even then, it is against the Fire code to do this. My Mom was set up in our family room. There was a bath down there and easy access to the outside to our cars. I did have child resistant covers on the doorknob so she could not get out. I was able to put a gate on her door that kept her from wandering my house at night. Maybe a dutch door can be put in. The bottom can be locked but the top kept open.

If Mom has no money, you can apply for Medicaid and place her in a nice Longterm care facility.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

Putting a lock on the door is fine if it prevents your mother from wandering at night when everyone is asleep. Locking her in at night is a lot safer than letting her wander all night or even leave the house. Residents are locked in when they're in a memory care facility.
The dog is not a good idea if the mother antagonizes it. Either the dog has to go or your mother has to. Maybe it's time to talk with your sister about next steps and placing your mother in memory care.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report
Geaton777 18 hours ago
The OP states the lock is to prevent interaction between the Mom and the dog, not about other wandering concerns. Dogs aren't nocturnal. Dogs can't unlock a door. Without more info from the OP it seems the Mom may be locked in there at other times of the day when the dog is awake.
(4)
Report
Oh HELL no!!! That is outright elder abuse and should be reported immediately.
This is WRONG on so many levels and it needs to stop today. Call Adult Protective Services first thing Monday morning and report this abuse. They will come out and if need be take over moms care, meaning they will get her placed in the appropriate facility where mom will be looked after 24/7 and be kept safe in the right ways.
To me this is NO different than keeping a child locked up in a closet all day.
If you truly love your mom you will stop this abuse today.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to funkygrandma59
Report
BurntCaregiver 18 hours ago
The OP does not say that her mother is locked in the bedroom all day and night long. There usually needs to be some kind of lock on the bedroom door when you're dealing with Alzheimer's to prevent the person from wandering or even leaving the house after everyone has gone to bed. This is for safety. Everyone will suggest baby monitors, cameras, or hire overnight caregivers. Here's the reality though. Everyone has to get a night's sleep especially if the family caregiver still has to go to a job every day. Most people can't afford to hire a bodyguard that follows a wandering demented elder all night long to keep them safe. Hence, the lock on the bedroom door.

The mother or the dog should be moved out. That's an disaster waiting to happen.
(3)
Report
See 2 more replies
First option: Put the lock on the inside of the door and talk M through putting it on when she goes to bed.

Or 2 (better): Put a latch that can be operated from inside or outside (but not by the dog). That will require drilling a hole through the door.

Or 3 (better still): Use a latch that can be operated from either side, but the inside option is tricky to work. I've seen these used in facilities for young residents (with the latch on the other way around), so that they can 'lock themselves in' but the staff can open the door with pliers if necessary.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report

isolate your mom because why???
A dog that is part of sister's family. Most dogs wag their tails into family settings.
You, your sister, and family, must make other arrangements for mom. Or, convince sister and her family to move dog...
mom needs help. The more this disease progresses, the more help mom will need...
sorry yours going through this.. don't be upset with the sister; she thought things would work. They are not.
Can you put mom into respite care while you find a better solution?
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to MAYDAY
Report
Worried03 2 hours ago
I understand she is trying to keep my mother there and it's a very hard situation. I myself have cared for Alzheimers patients and it's definitely not an easy job. But unfortunately I have no control over where my mom goes. That's frustrating for me because my siblings nor my children want to back me. Everyone else agrees with the situation. Thank you for your advice.
(0)
Report
Unlawful imprisonment. Elder abuse. Those are only two of the possible terms that come to mind. This situation needs to end so that mom gets the care she needs. You need to do whatever it takes to get mom out of there.

Your sister could be in big trouble if someone reports this to APS or other authorities. She’ll be in worse trouble if that dog hurts or kills your mother. I can’t believe anyone would think this arrangement is a good idea. Color me flabbergasted.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
Worried03 2 hours ago
My thoughts exactly! The dog has already attacked my mother. This is why she has a lock on the outside of her bedroom door to begin with (is why I'm told at least) but... Again I'm pretty sure this falls unlawful imprisonment as you said above. Makes my stomach sick. My siblings all agree with this action and my children are fine with it as well I feel alone and confused. I can only think about my scared mother when she tries to open the door but can't 😞
(0)
Report
How cruel to your mother. If you can’t reason with your sister to change this situation, please call Adult Protective Services in her county and report this
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

No. It is not acceptable. It is a fire hazard. It also blocks Mom from bathroom access and blocks Mom from getting a snack or drink from the kitchen.
If Mom gets injured it blocks Mom from getting help from others in the home.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to brandee
Report
BurntCaregiver 18 hours ago
Brandee,

A memory care facility is not going to let a resident get snacks from the kitchen at all hours. Definitely, there should be someone assisting in toileting the mother a few times in the overnight. There's a reason why memory care floros are locked. This is so residents can't wander off. Same thing applies to a private house. You can't allow someone with dementia to get up and wander around when everyone is in bed because they have to be supervised 24/7 like a toddler. A lock on the outside of the bedroom door is a safety measure.
(1)
Report
Your mother with Alzheimer's should not be living in your sister's home with the large dog, and definitely should not be locked in her bedroom!
If sister can't resolve the living arrangements to better accommodate your mother, then please find somewhere else for mom to live! Preferably a memory care assisted living facility. I'm sure neither you nor your sister are equipped to handle your mother's ongoing needs as her disease progresses. It gets much more challenging! It never gets easier. She will need cares and behave in ways that you never imagined, unless you have prior hands-on experience taking care of someone with Alzheimer's.
Please, get her comfortably situated in a nice, safe care home before this gets more dangerous.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report

Omg, what a terrible situation for your mother! Locking a human with dementia in a room so a big dog doesn't attack her. I've been here since 2015 and never heard a more cruel story.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

No, not legal. If a mandated reporter came into the house they would report that to APS.

The bigger question is why isn't she in AL? What's the point of cooping her up in her room? It seems cruel. No one would do that to an animal, no less their Mom... so you see where your sister's priorities lie.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
Worried03 1 hour ago
Agreed! My mom has a $3,500 retirement √ every month. Priority # 1 I'm guessing. Sick stuff! The sad thing is I have no family backing because everyone I'm related to is money oriented 😔
(0)
Report
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter