Follow
Share

My mom is in Assisted Living with an additional care package that includes medication management, shower assistance and reminders for ADLs, like help getting up in the mornings and choosing clean clothes, remembering to brush her teeth, etc. She has Mild Cognitive Impairment, no significant progression for years, so doc presumes it is not Alzheimer's, Lewy body, etc.
Her facility has two levels of Memory Care available, and I know they will recommend to me when they think she needs to move, but I'm seeing a decline in cleanliness after toileting, with some failures to get clean and I'm thinking that she may need more help with that.
What are the differences specifically between AL and MC at most facilities, in terms of the care given? (I know that socially, it will be a different population with less ability to form relationships and talk. She is NOT ready to move socially.). Can someone with some incontinence and cleanliness after toileting problems even stay in AL? Mom has a call button necklace, but isn't aware enough to USE it to get help after toileting.
Maybe there is a resource on this site that I haven't found that discusses the difference, but I'm also interested in people's experiences.
Thank you in advance!

Level of care and cost are the differences between MC, AL, and a NH.

Assisted living is for people who need some assistance with ADL's. It's usually the cheapest of the three. Residents go into AL for many reasons. Age is the main reason. Many have given up driving for example, or can't cook anymore, or need some help with getting in and out of the shower, and are old and don't want to be alone in their houses or apartments anymore. They are free to come and go because they are still physically and mentally able to do this safely. At the AL I was a staff supervisor in, our residents had the option for us to keep track of their medications and give them if they wanted that service. We assisted with showering (a few days a week on a schedule), meals, housekeeping, laundry, and socialization were provided. Residents could also sign up for shopping trips twice a week to but whatever things they wanted. Some residents still had cars and drove themselves. We did not provide baby-sitting service if a resident had dementia and couldn't be left alone. Then it was time for MC. Residents could use a cane if they had mobility issues but not a walker or wheelchair. They would have to go into a NH then. If incontinence was a problem, they had to go into a NH because we did not provide toileting or diaper changes. Many residents used disposable briefs or pads but had to be able to change and dispose of these properly themselves. Once in a while an aide would help if needed, but if it became a regular thing the resident had to go. AL's usually have rules like this.

A nursing home is when a person needs actual nursing care, or has serious mobility issues or illness, is incontinent all the time, and cannot meet any of their ADL's and is reliant on staff for everything. They may be mentally sound enough, but still need NH care.

Memory care is for people who cannot manage and are also reliant on others to keep them safe and meet their ADL's. These places are locked so residents cannot wander. Staff takes care of all of their care needs the same as in the NH. Hygiene care, medication, feeding, medication, and supervision 24/7. Most places don't provide the level of care and supervision these people need, but that's a profit and hiring problem and another conversation.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report

A good ALF will make the decision for you. At my mom's ALF, they say it will be time to move to MC when the patient becomes a danger to themselves and others -- ie., by wandering and getting lost, doing things like brushing their teeth with hand lotion instead of toothpaste, etc. Or, if their dignity is being compromised -- like if they are stripping off their clothes in public, screaming in the dining room, etc. I imagine frequently soiling their clothes due to incontinence could fall into that latter category.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to LilacGirl
Report

Memory Care shrinks down the environment for dementia patients so life is a lot easier for them. Theres no kitchenettes in MC, only a large bedroom and sitting area with an attached bathroom. Theres no temperature control to get confused by, no devices to learn, nothing. The bldg is set up in a square where all halls lead to the activiry room, so no getting lost. The activities are specialky geared to folks with limited abilities. 2 choices of foods are offered on red plates or blue plates, so residents point to which one they want. Food can be specially prepared, pureed or mechanical diets can be offered w/o a problem. Residents are taken to the bathroom every 2 hours. Or checked on in their rooms every 2 hours. There is a ton of difference between MC and AL. MC they keep a resident until death unless they are wreaking SUCH havoc and cannot be medicated to stay calm. The staff treated my mother like their grandmother at her MC. She came over from AL where everyone knew her and the male nurses were sent over to pick her up every time she fell. Sometimes 3x in one day.

When mom was dying with hospice, the aides asked if they could cut moms blouses in the back so they could dress her as she so loved. A line formed daily at her door to say goodbye.

Mom had terrible blowouts and nobody ever said a word. She was clean and lotioned 2x a week. Dressed to the nines daily, hair brushed with eyebrows all crooked and lipstick askew. But that didn't matter because she felt pretty.

MC can make a big difference for dignity with an elder suffering from dementia. And keep them out of a nursing home.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report
BabyGirl2 Jul 15, 2026
Thank you; this is a positive view of MC and it was encouraging.
(1)
Report
So far as I know, there is no legal definition of either Assisted Living or Memory Care. The clearest difference is that Memory Care is locked so people can’t leave. Assisted Living can be too, but it can also allow people to leave if they are able to. It depends on the ‘rules’ of the facility. There is more blurring that comes with different rules with different charges.

You need to ask your ‘own’ facility about the rules for the details that apply to you.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report

My mom is in memory care. Other patients need to be dressed, have diapers changed, fed, etc. Mom is one of the higher functioning ones there as she can dress herself, use the bathroom alone, but still needs to be bathed. Mom's MC also works with hospice when the time comes so the resident does not have to move. They do not allow feeding tubes or insulin shots. I don't think they will check blood sugars either. For us it's been the perfect placement for mom.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to JustAnon
Report
BabyGirl2 Jul 14, 2026
Good details, thanks and good luck with your Mom.
(1)
Report
My mom is similar. MCI for over a decade, getting the same supports in AL, very social. Are you sure that your mom doesn’t know how to call for assistance or maybe she doesn’t want to call for assistance with the bathroom? That is often the problem. In AL they can ask if the resident wants help with the bathroom, but the resident can just say no. In AL they can’t do what the resident refuses. I would ask the AL to be more assertive and proactive asking your mom if they can help change her briefs and getting her clean, but it may not work if your mom won’t cooperate or doesn’t think she needs the help. It’s a gray area and I’m also wondering when to pull the plug and move my mom to a smaller care home with fewer residents and more hands on care. A full blown MC seems like overkill with none of the other issues.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to ShirleyDot
Report
BabyGirl2 Jul 14, 2026
Thanks, yes, MC seems like a bit of overkill at this point. Yes, my mom really doesn't have the cognitive awareness to call for help. She tracked diarrhea all over her carpet before she realized the mess, for example. Very sad.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
AL is not always MC but MC is only AL unless it is provided within a SNF.

I learned that when I learned of a MC facility that was very impressive. My husband is not allowed there because he has a feeding tube because that requires SNF care. A MC facility is only AL level of care.

Some AL facilities have a special MC wing that is locked but that wing is still only AL.

Ask your facility if they provide incontinence care for an additional fee.

Just remember MCI (Mild Cognitive Impairment) sometimes progresses gradually to dementia and later can be identified as a specific type such as Alheimers, Lewy Bodies, Frontal Temporal or other identified named dementia.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to KPinSC
Report
BabyGirl2 Jul 14, 2026
"AL is not always MC but MC is only AL unless it is provided within a SNF." -- Interesting point, and I did not know that. This is an AL facility only, but with two self-contained MC wings at two different levels of care. The staff ratio is lower and the residents get more hands on help with ADLs. I'll look into it further, thanks.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
When Assisted Living may no longer be enough...

Many professionals suggest it's time to consider memory care when the answer to one or more of these questions becomes "yes":

Is the person unsafe if left alone for even short periods?
Are they wandering or trying to leave?
Do they need frequent redirection throughout the day?
Are they becoming distressed because they're confused?
Is their behavior affecting other residents?
Are staff spending far more time with them than an assisted living setting is designed to provide?

Often the facility itself will make the recommendation. Whether someone is graduated from AL to MC often depends on the facility. All your current concerns should be discussed with the admins sooner rather than later.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
BabyGirl2 Jul 13, 2026
Thank you for the answer -- all of those questions are good ones, and the current answer to all is "no." I am in meetings with the residential life director, and they don't think that she needs to move up to memory care yet. But I guess I am worrying in advance, and it seems to me that the soiling problems might be a game changer at this point.
(1)
Report
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter