Follow
Share

Last Saturday I stayed in our local ER for 7 hours, 3 of which were waiting for physical therapist to come and evaluate me and educate me as to how to use a walker. Seems like a huge waste of Medicare/Insurance funds. Am sending a complaint form to the hospital but I suspect nothing will happen. Anyone have this experience and what did you do? I heard that the ER has to keep a Medicare patient for at least 4 hours to get reimbursed. Hope this isn't true!

You are lucky the ER was accepting patients as mine is usually on diversion and you have to drive 2 hours to get to a place that has an open ER.

A 7 hour wait is NOTHING these days. That is average. Were you in the hallway on a gurney or on a room. If you were in a room, you really have nothing to complain about.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to southernwave
Report

I agree with Southernwave. A 7-hour ER wait around here is considered quick. Hell, the last time my husband had to go with a kidney stone, we waited 7 hours just to be brought into an exam bay, and that's with him being in extreme pain with the stone.

And as far as the ER not getting paid unless the patient is there for 4 hours - I suspect you are confusing the rules about time frame spent in the ER and being admitted under Medicare- I forget the actual rule and wording, but it's something to do with you can be in the ER up to 48 hours without being considered "admitted". The ER will get paid for treatment rendered whether it takes 4 hours or 4 minutes.

Like all other places, there are too many patients and not enough medical personnel to handle them in a timely fashion. Also, more and more doctors are refusing to see patients when they are sick (??), or else they can't fit a patient in for an appointment for weeks, so many people don't have a choice but to go to the ER for something they might ordinarily see their PCP.

I also suspect that ER's don't really WANT to speed people through, because then even more people will be more tempted to go to the ER rather than their PCP for every little thing.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to notgoodenough
Report

I've never been to the ER for less than 4 hours, with or w/o Medicare! It's no "fraud or scam" either, it's real life in overcrowded hospitals these days. Sending a complaint to the hospital is a waste of time. If you don't want to wait in the future, go to Urgent Care instead of the ER or better yet, make a doctors appointment because UC can take hours too. I don't know a soul who needs instruction on how to use a walker!
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

They must have been very busy.
Unfortunately, by the nature of insurance changes, many will now be unlikely to afford insurance, and our ERs will be even more full.
Very sorry this was the case. I imagine you will get the rote response. But glad you are writing them.

My own ER experience I would say was at least that long. Arrived. Waited to be seen. Was seen. Long history taken. IV placed. Eventually a CT scan to r/o kidney stone they suspected. Came back negative for findings. Pain remained. Were expecting a doctor in to read a complicated scan on another patient. Ran it by him. He found a diverticulitis in the Transverse bowel, unusual place for it. Medications ordered. And yeah, between each step a whole lot of waiting with others all around and in pain.

ERs admit and work around a constant "triage" which I had to do as an RN when floated there. When the stab wound comes in, your broken and now set arm goes to back burner fast, and it's all hands on deck.

Afraid it's a matter of timing.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

No, that’s not true. There is no rule requiring an Emergency Room (ER) to keep a Medicare patient for at least 4 hours in order to get reimbursed. Medicare reimburses based on the services provided — not on time spent. (source: ChatGPT5)

The last several times I've been in the ER with my Mom (age 96) here in MN in a metro/suburban hospital, we waited 8 hrs. Then another trip to an ER in suburban FL last spring. Even longer than 8 hrs.

FYI I grew up in a bedroom community of NYC. Back then (1970s) the average wait in an ER was 8 hrs.

Nowadays, the US is short 30,000 doctors and the Boomers are mostly all above 65 now and needing a lot of healthcare resources. It's going to be this way for the foreseeable future.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to Geaton777
Report

Two questions. Were you waiting in the ER overnight? I never heard of PT being av24vhour department. They usually punch in at 7 am.
If you had an orthopedic injury, perhaps you should research if large orthopedic offices. They are popping up as an alternative to urgent care.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to MACinCT
Report

Wait times in ERs are insane these days. People go in for any reason at all.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to JustAnon
Report
ShirleyDot Nov 19, 2025
Sadly, many people who can't afford insurance use the ER for things that should be handled by a PCP or urgent care because that is their only choice.
(1)
Report
My mother-in-law's last ER visit was a nightmare. She waited in the waiting room for about 8 hours, then they put her in a bed in the hallway. It was 24 hours before she was actually given a room. That was, by far, the worst of recent ER visits.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Stardust
Report

Part of the problem is that people don't actually have primary care doctors or even insurance so they use the ER like an Urgent Care or a clinic.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Geaton777
Report

If we use any of our local ER’s we know the time will be long, it’s just a given. Yes, we’ve had the experience, and there’s nothing an individual can do to change it
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report

The one way to avoid a lengthy ER visit is to enter via ambulance. HOWEVER, this is often not covered, and almost never if it isn't a true life/death emergency. When my partner had a stroke it was 911. He was in and on his way to clot busters within 25 minutes. Had we entered through the door we may have been correctly triaged to immediate care and we may not; that would have been dependent on the expert skills of the ER personnel.

An ambulance comes with enormous cost in dollars at times, but you will be delivered into a cubicle unless they are on serious divert triage and you are in a hallway--you WILL have hospital personnel on you at once and they will have been communicating with the ambulance as you enter.

Folks, our health care system, as regards this, is bad and going to get much much worse as people drop their insurance now. This is a good warning to us all.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report
lealonnie1 Nov 15, 2025
My mother went to the ER by ambulance at $100 copay per visit and we STILL spent more than 4 hours there each and every time.
(4)
Report
See 3 more replies
My father loved his ER trips. Club Med as I called it. The problem was he thought I enjoyed them equally as he did. Hours in the waiting room then more hours in a stall. 9 times out of 10 my father was there for non-ER related issues. This was my father's entertainment and my personal Hell. Sometimes he would get himself to the ER then I would get a middle of the night call to come and pick him up. I learned to stop answering the phone.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to lkdrymom
Report
MACinCT Nov 15, 2025
I worked evening shifts in a hospital. My mom would go to an ER via ambulance for high sugars around 7 pm. I could not leave due to chronic poor staffing and I could not abandon my 6 to 8 ICU patients. I was not a nurse carrying a lower load and no coverage if I left.
I would call mom's ER to let them know to contact me when she needed discharge. I would not go rushing to stay with her while she was in good care and probably sleeping. Staying with her till almost sunrise would not help if I had to return to work the next evening.
(5)
Report
They may have been able to right up an "in home" order for PT in your home. Which would have been better because the therapist could have evaluated your home for safety and show you how to use your walker around the house.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report
dkiely33 Nov 18, 2025
*write up* ....not right up
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Next time go to Urgent Care. Or, my doctor's office has an emergency service there for days when the doctors aren't in, such as weekends and holidays. I've used that, and it was efficient. But - if I'd been really sick, they'd have sent me to the hospital ER.

It's important to have several plans of action in place for different scenarios..
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Fawnby
Report

ER visits routinely take many, many hours. If your issue can be handled at an Urgent care, go there first.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to RedVanAnnie
Report
TouchMatters Nov 19, 2025
URGENT CARE is what I was going to recommend.
Make sure it is covered on your insurance.

I'm confused though why a PT appt is considered an emergency?
Aren't these kinds of appts made in advance through an MD referral.
A social worker or nurse or assistant at MD office should be able to assist with walker usage.

Gena / Touch Matters
(0)
Report
When I worked at a veterinary emergency hospital I would tell people that we had to triage the animals and we didn’t work on a first come first serve basis and that long waits could be a good sign since your pet wasn’t going to die without immediate attention.
On the funny side, at one point I was bitten by a dog at work. I had to go to the ER though it wasn’t a bad bite but since I was at work when it happened I still had to go. The vet I was working with cleaned the bite and put a temporary bandage on it using red vet wrap since that happened to be the color we had at the time. When I got to the ER I received immediate attention because they thought the bandage was totally soaked with blood! I had to reassure them that I was fine to wait!
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Animallovers
Report
ShirleyDot Nov 19, 2025
That's great hack, lol!
(0)
Report
sad4sis: Speak to the hospitalist.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Llamalover47
Report
LakeErie Nov 19, 2025
Speak to the resident doctor? How would that be helpful? And how would you get an appointment to do so?
(3)
Report
It doesn’t seem like learning to use a walker is much of an emergency, but unfortunately lots of people just think of ER as a doctor’s office where you don’t need an appointment, just a long wait. Fortunately when I had my heart attack the cardiologist seemed to be waiting at the door. for the ambulance, stents in hand. If I’d had to wait while they thought someone how to use a walker I wouldn’t be writing this.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Harrylcnm
Report
SamTheManager Nov 20, 2025
They always put the people in order of urgency and a heart attack or stroke is going to get closer to the top of the list as you must be treated right away to avoid further life threatening damage or death. I'm glad they took you in order of your issue vs the order you arrived in, so that you are here today.
(2)
Report
ER generally takes hours and hours and hours, no matter your age. I don't think there's anything you can do about it. I was there last month with my mom. She fell was taken to the hospital to be checked out. By the time they did the x-rays, then a CT Scan, she'd been there 11 hours. It just takes time. The ER was incredibly busy. She didn't seem to mind. She was in a bed and just kind of snoozed a lot.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Jacquelinezr
Report

Well I agree with the others. My mother in an AFH went to the ER. Her caregiver went with her. A UTI was suspected due to symptoms. 6 and a half hrs later, determined that none was evident and they went home. Its just what happens.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Littlewing65
Report

Thank you all for your responses. I went to the ER due to SEVERE back pain. The ER was not all that busy - nurse who wheeled me out said they were real steady but not busy, busy. I didn't have to wait all that long in the waiting room. Essentially it was for the physical therapist. She was an on-call person so don't know if that had any significance. My back pain was so severe that I didn't think a visit to urgent care was a good idea. Just concerned for the long "down time" wait and the cost to Medicare and secondary insurances.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to sad4sis
Report
ShirleyDot Nov 19, 2025
If you are waiting for someone on-call, you get them when they are available. Or you leave and make an appointment.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
When my mother had a heart attack a few months ago she was taken by ambulance to the ER. She was in excruciating pain; we were put in a hallway with a drunk psych patient next to her. I waited with her for 24 hours before she was admitted and had to pester the nurse (who was very caring but very busy) for repeated doses of morphine for my mom. She was finally admitted and had a stent put in very soon after. I was grateful to be able to be with her b/c I had to advocate a lot for her needs. This is in Boston at a world-class hospital. It is what it is. The docs and nurses were amazing, the wait was awful. Thanks for letting me share my little story. Not unusual (a friend told me her mother had to wait 48 hrs to be admitted one time at that hospital so I guess I should be grateful!)
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Emilyschild
Report

Can you wait somewhere else nearby and have the ER call you when they are ready to see you? Maybe a nearby restaurant, movie theater, bowling facility, just thinking outside of the box.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to johnawheeler
Report

Sounds pretty typical for Upstate NY
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to JeanLouise
Report

I want to clarify that Medicare does NOT pay claims based on time in ER.

Sadly, ER wait times are quite long across the country. Seven hours is not out of the ordinary or an extraordinary wait time. Many ER wait times are 7 hours before you even get into a room.

You can most certainly send a complaint if you wish. There will be a filter down to the ER staff. Many times the ER is over saturated with patients and staff can needs to efficiently access patients to give them the best healthcare possible.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to AMZebbC
Report

16 hours to get my husbands Foley catheter replaced. a simple procedure that takes about 15 minutes. Most spent waiting just to be seen by a Dr or PA. Another visit he was there 8 hours with Diabetic Ketoacidosis which I knew he had, the EMTs said they suspected he had ,but the triage nurse said no as he had no fever.. He could have died but a stupid triage nurse gummed up the works. You better believe I've complained, wrote letters to the editor, put my experiences on Facebook. Guess what? Nothing happened. ERs are horrible.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Greengrammy24
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter